Dan Carlin's Hardcore History.
He tries to look at history through the eyes of people at that time and not from a distance. E.g. instead of talking about great strategies etc he focuses on what it meant to be raided by Ghengis Khan.
this post was submitted on 28 Apr 2025
53 points (98.2% liked)
Ask Lemmy
31335 readers
1367 users here now
A Fediverse community for open-ended, thought provoking questions
Rules: (interactive)
1) Be nice and; have fun
Doxxing, trolling, sealioning, racism, and toxicity are not welcomed in AskLemmy. Remember what your mother said: if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all. In addition, the site-wide Lemmy.world terms of service also apply here. Please familiarize yourself with them
2) All posts must end with a '?'
This is sort of like Jeopardy. Please phrase all post titles in the form of a proper question ending with ?
3) No spam
Please do not flood the community with nonsense. Actual suspected spammers will be banned on site. No astroturfing.
4) NSFW is okay, within reason
Just remember to tag posts with either a content warning or a [NSFW] tag. Overtly sexual posts are not allowed, please direct them to either !asklemmyafterdark@lemmy.world or !asklemmynsfw@lemmynsfw.com.
NSFW comments should be restricted to posts tagged [NSFW].
5) This is not a support community.
It is not a place for 'how do I?', type questions.
If you have any questions regarding the site itself or would like to report a community, please direct them to Lemmy.world Support or email info@lemmy.world. For other questions check our partnered communities list, or use the search function.
6) No US Politics.
Please don't post about current US Politics. If you need to do this, try !politicaldiscussion@lemmy.world or !askusa@discuss.online
Reminder: The terms of service apply here too.
Partnered Communities:
Logo design credit goes to: tubbadu
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Three Arrows on Youtube for history for the first half of the last century. Has strong emphasis of the comparison of pre- and interwar politics and contemporary events.
If you go this Youtube channel, you'll first be greeted by videos about Jordan Peterson and the likes (and how they misrepresent historical events), but the guy behind the channel also has a podcast that is purely about history without analysis of current reception of historical events.
- Fall of Civilizations
- Dan Carlin
- The Rest is History
- Cautionary Tales
- The Delicious Legacy
I know you said no voice-reading-text and wanted personality, but for my money nothing is better background listening than History of English. You can listen to the whole narrative of an episode or just pick up some cool etymology here and there.
Others have mentioned Hardcore History -- probably the pinnacle of history podcasting, but the episodes are VERY long (a lot are upwards of 4 hours) and you're lucky if he puts out more than 2 per year. He does other shorter Addenda episodes that come out more frequently, but they're not the same format, usually interviews.
History of Rome -- it's older, but it basically started the "History of [nation/civilization]" podcast format. Does an excellent job tracing Roman history from the founding of the city up to the fall of the Western empire in the 5th century.
Revolutions -- same host as History of Rome. After he finished HoR he started this one. Each 'season' tracks a different historical world revolution (English, American, French, Mexican, Haitian, Russian, and more). Overall, the entire series tracks large-scale western political history from the 17th century up to the early 20th. He ended the podcast after he finished the Russian Revolution. But then he restarted it a couple of years later, running a season on the fictional Martian Revolution of the 24th century. This is on going now, with 6 episodes left. He's said he's going back to pick up on historical revolutions after the Russian when he finishes with Mars, teasing Ireland and Iran as future seasons.
Behind the Bastards -- Dives into various horrible people from history with a special focus on world dictators/authoritarians, cult leaders, grifters, and quack doctors. He tends to focus on more recent history (past 50-100 years) but sometimes goes into older history.
Cool People Who Did Cool Stuff -- An inversion of Behind the Bastards from the same podcast network. Tends to focus on radical political history with a special focus on anarchists, women, and lgbtq people.
Came here to recommend Behind the Bastards and Cool People Who Did Cool Stuff!
I'll throw in The Dollop as well.
At the risk of being super obvious... Give Hardcore History a try. It's long, highly subjective, and the subject matter tends toward intense subjects.
Blueprint for Armageddon, King of Kings, and Destroyer of Worlds are absolutely fantastic episodes.
Let's be real, they're audiobooks
The only reason I'd say they aren't is because Dan Carlin doesn't use a fully written script. A lot of history podcasters write out a full script and read it out, basically the same thing as an audiobook. Dan Carlin just has an outline with a bunch of notes and quotes he wants to use. When he records he does it off the top of his head.
I noticed a big difference a few years ago when he released an actual book, The End is Always Near. He recorded an official audiobook of it. You can really tell the difference in his style between the podcast and the audiobook.
Yes, so much. I listened to that book and his writing voice is a lot less natural, almost stilted. I'm so used to his style of highly refined extemporising that hearing him read aloud weirds me out. Dan if you're in danger blink twice! Help is on the way just do whatever they ask!
I'm also so accustomed to his normal podcasting voice that when he does interviews where he's just having a conversation with someone else it really weirds me out. Like, dude, you're not supposed to be talking like a normal person just having a conversation. You're supposed to be describing the most extreme examples of the human condition in poetic terms.
It's really jarring. Especially when someone makes him laugh? It's like hearing Bob Ross shriek. You don't do that.
This is my pick too.
Also, if you're into the history of Rome, give "The History of Rome" by Mike Duncan a listen. It's old, so the first few episodes are of a questionable audio quality. But he gets a new microphone pretty early on, and it gets easier to listen to. He talks about the entire history of Rome, starting with Romulus and Remus and going pasthrough the republic, then the empire and up to the 5th century. The episodes are nice and short, and mistakes are always rectified if need be one or two episodes later.
And once you've finished History of Rome, move right on to Mike Duncan's next podcast, Revolutions.
It's a similar format as HoR, except each 'season' follows a different historical revolution with the overall series roughly tracking large-scale wester political history from the 18th century to the early 20th century. He's covered the English Civil War, American Revolution, French Revolution, Haitian Revolution, Spanish-American Independence, July Revolution, 1848 Revolutions, Mexican Revolution, and Russian Revolution.
He then officially ended the podcast, but a couple of years later he restarted it with a fictional Martian Revolution set in the 24th century. Again, same format as above, but entirely fictional and heavily informed by his study of various world revolution. This is currently ongoing with 6ish episodes left.
He's also said that once the Martian Revolution is done he plans on starting back up with the historical revolutions, picking right back up after the Russian Revolution.
Came here to say revolutions! It’s real good.
Behind The Bastards isn't a general history podcast, but what it covers is history.
Hardcore history is one of my favorites.
The Block back Podcast is a great one that goes into detail of the US doing fucked up evil shit around the world. Each season is a different country and they have Afghanistan, Cuba, North Korea, and Iraq.
https://blowback.show/ also provides all the sources used, can be found on any podcast service. It's done by two great journalists and they also interview people who have direct experience with the conflict, such as independent journalists who were on-the-ground
Fall of Civilizations podcast has a YT channel. It’s excellent.
The fall of civilization is really cool
By far my favorite, though I suppose OP may not like it, as it is just the (monotonous, but nice sounding) voice of the narrator, without enthusiasm, jokes or personal takes
I'm also not sure if it's what OP is looking for, but I also think Fall of Civilisations is not quite as dry as other history podcasts.
He does a great job of painting a picture through the narration, making you imagine what it would be like to have lived in those times. And he sometimes does add his personal takes (always clearly pointed out as personal takes).
It might still be too narrative for OP, but it might also be colourful enough.
Well I'm not going to discard it outright, maybe if it's really well written in a way I like, it's still engaging enough. I'd rather err on the side of too many options than too few. Thanks for the suggestions
I am personally a big fan of Voices of the Past and Fall of Civilisations.
Voices is very specific in what it does. It doesn't actually give you a historian's perspective, it's strictly primary sources translated into English and then read out as-is. Since it makes absolutely no attempt to account for material evidence or the biases of the authors it is much more about the perspective of individuals from the time than recounting accurate history, but I think that's very interesting
As its name suggests, Fall focusses on the end of civilisations, ranging from the Greenland Norse and Rapa Nui to Han China and Byzantium.
It doesn't hurt that the speakers in both have very pleasant voices
The Rest is History. Good banter between the hosts. Huge backlog on a variety of topics.
Origin Story. This one might be a little outside your wheelhouse, or might not, depending on what you're after. Specifically, it talks about the origins (and thus the history) mostly of political ideologies like neoliberalism and zionism, political figures like Thatcher, Churchill, and Jordan Peterson, and movements or terms like the Suffragettes and the term "woke".
BBC's You're Dead To Me is good if you want something a bit light. There's a regular host who's joined by a comedian and a historian. Covers a different topic each time.
Mike Duncan's The History of Rome and Revolutions podcasts (particularly the French Revolution series).
Oldest Stories Podcast
History with Cy
Both doing Mesopotamian antiquity, and Egypt as well for Cy. Both on Youtube.
I absolutely love Throughline. They have some very interesting content and I like how they fuse it together with with a good soundstage, it can be quite cinematic. The only two downsides: You kind of have to pay attention Some episodes can be a bit depressing, so I've heard from people I've recommended the show to in the past.
https://www.npr.org/podcasts/510333/throughline
Edit:
BtB is my favorite, but that's already been mentioned. Our Fake History is my second favorite and also very worth a listen!
Their angle on things is addressing points in history that, for one reason or another, have been misrepresented or misremembered, but they get into all sorts of topics, so that's not always their explicit goal.
There is also This Podcast Will Kill You, which is more a science show than history, but they always have a history segment on whatever their subject is (mostly viruses, infections, diseases, and occasionally poisons and disorders). The hosts are both named Erin. That's not relevant to the thread. I just think it's funny.
Second for The Rest is History. Its on all major podcast platforms and on YouTube. It has two hosts who take it in turns to talk about a topic while the other asks questions. Its full of gentle banter, and light humour but deleves in depth into topics. Some topics are covered in a single episode, others in depth in multi part series.
Its got a huge backlog of episodes, clearly labeled by topic and covers the full breadth of history. The two hosts are British but it covers global history, and it doesnt have biases. It does a "warts and all" approach to any topic.
Strongly recommend it.
English only? Asking because the Barbero podcast (in Italian) is great. As a person who hated studying history in school I can spend hours listening this.
English and Spanish, unfortunately I don't speak Italian. I should learn to perhaps, I like the way it sounds.
While the podcast is great, maybe not great enough to learn a new language for it! Although Spanish is very close!
I think 99% Invisible might have some episodes up your alley.
Some of the episodes are about more modern-day topics, but a good majority of them involve historical events and figures.
Michael Troy has the uncreatively name American Revolution Podcast which is basically a full episode per event/battle between the French Indian War beyond the signing of the Constitution. Leans more history than entertainment but there's some deadpan humor in there.
just a voice reading a text [...] Simon Whistler
The ultimate voice reading a text IMO. Specifically, a voice reading a text that it has clearly never seen before and where the producers have not even bothered to explain how to pronounce the names in it. IMO Simon Whistler is like Justin Bieber - essentially a product of the YouTube algorithm. In this case, a hipstery guy with an amazing beard and a posh authoritative accent talking confidently about... whatever. To me it just screams inauthenticity. But it's obviously what people want so congrats to him for riding the gravy train.
Honestly that's part of the fun of it. I love when he reacts to the information incredulously, "What? Is that really it??"
History of Everything is pretty good.
AltHistoryHub, while the main focus isn't actual history obviously, but he gives a lot of context from the real history.
Tasting History is food focused but also gives you the historical context around the dishes he makes as well.
I really like the Short History Of podcast; the narrator speaks well, it’s interesting and well written.
Reallifelore covers both historic and current events, usually around 1 hour per video.
I also found these lectures+interviews with Sarah Paine very compelling https://youtu.be/LbkO84MsmyM
https://www.learnoutloud.com/Results/Author/Barbara-W.-Tuchman/14182
Listen to these books on audio.
Lions Led by Donkeys is a military history podcast. I enjoy the host's sense of humor as much as the history.
view more: next ›