Your post doesn't mention the "I want to share it with my friends" psychology

I've always agreed, but I'm in my 30s and have never understood the appeal of social media. I will say I do occasionally enjoy watching other people's concert footage because there are some artists that I'd genuinely like to follow from stop to stop like a deadhead or a phish stan, but obviously can't in this economy lol.

Not to belabor the point, I just wanted to post something tangential I think about: I believe a few candids of interesting-but-not-that-interesting moments can score a critical hit in 20-30 years. One of them will hit like the food inspector in Ratatouille. The voice of a friend who's not around for one reason or another, a place that used to be common, some hobby you've dropped, or a moment when you were giggling can flip your life upside down for a second. I took excruciating notes every night while I was abroad just in case one day I want to relive it.

nah, im in my mid-20s and have always felt the same way. all the boomers and gen x i know are obsessed with capturing every moment on film. me and my gf both never take pictures and my mom and her mom both always ask for pics when we do something and we usually have almost nothing. we went on a week long vacation halfway across the country and when we sent the pics to them there were like 15 and some of them where the same pic at different angles.

i think it just takes you out of the moment. if i want to remember it ill just use my head. if i forget, it wasn’t important anyways. ill take pictures very sparingly bc they are nice to look back on but having too many would discourage me from looking at them and obscure the truly important moments. even in important moments ill take just a few pics bc i want to stay in the moment

While I feel pretty much exactly the same I have softened on it a little. A family member admitted to me that she does this when I brought it up once, and when I mentioned the point you make about making memories she just said to me "your memory is way better than mine."

She probably isn't gonna look at those photos and nobody else is gonna look but I kinda decided that people are allowed to cling to their experiences in the face of entropy however they like. (Tbh I will still probably be rolling my eyes at this behavior but, like, compassionately somehow.)

Same. I totally understand taking a few pictures for later so you can reminisce a bit about the stuff you did, but folks have an obsession with "I need to setup the perfect 6 photographs of my weekend to show everyone on Instagram" and I think that specifically is extremely unhealthy

It's been years since I last went to a concert and the reason is that standing in a crowd of people looking at the concert through their phones just felt weird and unpleasant.

I mostly agree, but there is some subtlety.

Taking pictures of an event or thing is pretty weird. But taking a few pictures of friends and family is great. Going to the zoo to take a picture of an animal is pretty silly, but getting a quick snap of my kids seeing a giraffe for the first time is pretty great. Same with taking a selfie with my friends at a concert. Obviously, I’m not spending a lot of time trying to set up an instagram perfect photo, just a quick candid here and there.

I love seeing them show up in various timeline apps and albums later and remembering the day.

In short, take quick pictures of your loved ones and then enjoy the moment.

I'd say it's a little of both.

People of all ages are certainly conditioned to record and photograph every little thing out of the ordinary, which takes away from being present. Phones in general are incredibly distracting from taking you out of the moment.

It's also incredible technology the ability to capture any photo/video at any time. There's no real tangible loss of taking too many pictures ie you aren't wasting any film/money.

Photos/video are really just a way to remember the past. People in the 90s would record pretty benign stuff too with camcorders and cameras, just the tech was more expensive and not readily affordable and available like it is today.

Also the zoo in particular brings out the nature photographer larp. Documenting nature in the wild takes an incredible amount of skill, luck, and patience. At the zoo you cut out all the hard work and get the instant gratification of shots which would be borderline impossible irl

Is anyone going to look back fondly on sleeping zoo animals or shaky concert footage? Prob not. I just think the conditioning of it is a way to help us remember the past, so at the end of the day it's only mildly annoying at worst, and pretty harmless.

I think a better example of technology alienation is a couple/family all scrolling on their phones during dinner together.

A counter perspective I guess: As a person who doesn't take photos or appear in photos (I think there are fewer than ten photos of me in existence, at various ages), I've sometimes thought about how devastating it would be to my sense of self if I lose my memory when I get older and don't have any sort of artifact (like a photo) I can use to bring any of it back.

I still don't take pictures though, it's just not a habit I've formed.

Do people really go back and look at these images and videos and feel the same feeling as when they’re looking a marmoset of exotic bird right in the eyes a few feet away from them?

No but I did go to a really sick zoo six months ago and I still go back and look at the pics and videos I took occasionally

My family, in general, hate being in pictures. But i do have one uncle who's been into photograohy for his entire life. He documented all sorts of slice of life stuff that isn't really captured all that well in video. Lived in Toronto during the 70s and Montreal in the 80s. Always found interesting scenes no matter where he was. His photobooks are just moments in time, but really captured what it was like. It's one of those things that i do as well, to capture slices of life.

I never got into taking pictures for memories, I only take them to send to other people. I'm probably at the other end of the spectrum, but that is likely due to depression.

Will never understand the urge that roughly 1/4 of people who go to concerts have of whipping out and filming on their phones though. A picture I can understand.

My job actually depends on people taking as many photos of their life as possible so I'm directly contributing sorryyyyy

Do people go back and look at these things? No, almost never. If you want to take a picture and actually find yourself looking at it again at some point in the future you really need to print it out and put it in a frame or album. Digital stuff is cheap and easy to create, but that makes it huge and ephemeral and awkward to come back to later.

i'm also an old, though i'm the "young one" out of my most immediate family, not including my sibling's kid who is like 12. when we all go to things, me and the kid are the one who actually look around at shit. the others, the boomers and the gen x, all have their phones out and are trying to frame the world around them onto their little handheld screens to take pictures and videos literally zero people will ever give a shit about, though maybe 8 people will click "like" on it when it goes by their feed, because it's not an advertisement, a toxic-positivity affirmation, or an incoherent political screed blaming educated women and immigrants for problems.

i take pictures on vacation sometimes, but generally stuff that is just for me to remember a detail that would blur into the trip years later. the place in western new mexico i stopped to get gas that was 45°F on a summer morning. the brand new but absolutely shot-to-shit forest service trail sign leading back into town. little chronological markers. sometimes i take a picture of signage to remember the exact feature so i can look up info later.

it feels very different than, as you describe, the people walking around with their phones, watching the penguins through the camera hoping to capture some meme-worthy moment digitally while ignoring the rich analog happening around them. i can also tell you, my family for the most part does not go back and look through old photos. they do accumulate them on old laptops and ask for help migrating them over to new computers, with helpful names like "New Folder (3)", "old phone", "2010" and "Europe". and as they age, they can't really place where the pictures were taken in their own memory, because all they remember is focusing taking the picture... not their surroundings or the context. so there's like a poorly framed picture of some building or a town that looks distinct and interesting, but nobody knows where or what it is. multiply that by 1000.

it's a rare and talented person with incredible equipment who can get a really good photo of a feature or place that also conveys the energy, vibe, and emotion of those who behold it. and fortunately, those people exist, do that and sell photos online that can be framed, etc. not to mention, people paint and sculpt things to that can be souvenirs. and for going down a more informal memory lane, one can nearly always look up the place they went online and look at the tagged photos others have uploaded to be reminded. so all the individual camera wielding feels counter productive to memory making when there, in the present.

They are probably sharing it with people who aren’t there.
Take a Prozac, gramps.

Going places costs money. Often, a lot of money. I need something permanent to make it not feel like I'm just throwing money away on an experience I will forget.

People have been spoiled by the ability to take infinite pictures. Film cameras - while wasteful and complicated - provide you with limited frames. The moments captured may be imperfect, blurry, someone's eyes closed, but I believe those have more value because it shows that the moment was truly lived in rather than an artificial setup to capture "perfection". I think if you absolutely need to document everything, you should be limited to truly value your present time as well as the past.

3 things are usually true:

• Someone else has taken better video of the same moment
• The chances of the person in question returning to this video are vanishingly small
• It will end up as just another thing to scroll past

I'll try to capture moments to share with friends/family I wish were there to see with me. Otherwise ya big alienation moment.

Taking constant photos or videos to post online feels like bragging to me and i dont understand it. Its hard to enjoy the moment which can be so fleeting. But i do take pictures if I see something that I think will make a neat picture. Do I ever go back and look at them? No, almost never.

Mas o menos. I really think a balance should be struck. I got so many videos and pictures that mostly take up space, but if something is truly amazing I forget to pull out my phone.