this post was submitted on 04 Jan 2026
65 points (100.0% liked)
Chapotraphouse
14230 readers
952 users here now
Banned? DM Wmill to appeal.
No anti-nautilism posts. See: Eco-fascism Primer
Slop posts go in c/slop. Don't post low-hanging fruit here.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Adventurism defenders are the exact same as vote blue libs. Yes let's keep trying the same thing that has literally never worked! It'll definitely work if we just do one more adventure! The only reason it hasn't worked is because we just need to do one more! Just one more adventure and this time, unlike literally all of the other times, we'll see widespread systemic change! Just one more bro! Just one more adventure!
Ridiculous and frankly reactionary ideology. Random acts of violence against individuals alone do not and cannot and have not solved any widespread systemic issue. There are real solutions that can exist and do exist. Go do those things rather than daydream about something that doesn't accomplish anything meaningful.
The assassination of CEO Brian Thompson accomplished quite a bit. It galvanized lots of people, showing everyone that not only are these billionaire CEOs not untouchable, but that there is widespread approval for using violence against them. It showed millions of people that they aren't alone in thinking "yeah, those capitalist fuckers who exploit us and profit off our misery really should die." I know several mostly apolitical people that before that would have said "violence is always wrong" but afterward started saying they think people like Thompson deserve what happened to him and never would have felt comfortable saying so before.
Yes, many radical leftists are no different than this other group we all agree are bad. Great argument.
What does it mean to have "worked"? Has it overthrown the bourgeoisie? No. But neither has all the organization efforts ever conducted in the imperial core. If that's what it means for a tactic to have "worked," then when you say "Yes let's keep trying the same thing that has literally never worked!" then you have to say the same thing about organizing, which we all agree is absurd. But if you change your definition of "worked" to "helping move things in the right direction," then individual acts HAVE worked many times and in different ways. They've failed and had a negative effect at times too, but so have organizations and attempted vanguard parties. Red Army Faction being an example.
Disingenuous to call them "random," because specific individuals being targeted is anything but random. And while these acts may not be able to "solve" systemic issues on their own, that doesn't mean they can't be powerful demonstrations or have any positive effect.
What are those real solutions, then? If they were complete solutions then either they would have solved things by now, or they haven't been tried yet. If they haven't been tried yet, then enlighten us all and tell us how to free ourselves from capitalism. If they HAVE been tried then obviously they aren't complete solutions and you aren't on any better footing than people who do advocate for adventurism. It takes all kinds.
Name a positive long term systemic change that happened as a result of this
Whenever positive systemic change happened in history, the events were rebranded as "fighting for freedom". Literally all positive systemic change happened this way throughout the history. French peasents beheaded soldiers, that's how they got democracy. If they had failed, the events would have been known as a "terrorist attack". But the important thing is, there has to be a social movement behind the actions. Individual attacks may spark the initial flame, but if there is no movement behind it the flame won't last for long. That's the thing you are right about. No matter how many times this happens, it will not result in any change unless there is also a social movement behind it.
Didn't the assassination of Shinzo Abe actually get that right wing cult be purged from Japan?
One of them. But now they have a Nazi president so