I know I’ll probably be downvoted for saying this, but there are a lot of really good managers out there. None of them, however, have a degree in business.

middle and upper management and llm are incompetent, but llm would at least not have an ego about it

I have observed a strong correlation between managers whose emails are now obviously written by AI and those who have significant shortcomings.

Middle management seems like exactly the kind of jobs that LLMs could actually replace and do a good job at.

We individual contributors do the actual creative work and make gears of industry turn.

The owners at the top will want to stay rich and stay in control because obviously being rich means they are "one of the good ones"

All the layers of hierarchy in between? Their main functions are to filter all the information about their department to send up the chain, or to take the marching orders from above and fill in the details for everybody below them. With some human margin of error. And that's the best case scenario is somebody who actually does their job and does it well.

Filtering data into summaries, generating new data from simple high-level descriptions, and not doing it "correctly" or "optimally" but "believably?" I think we found the job LLMs were invented to replace!!

(in reality, I'd much rather see $100,000 salaries go to 100,000 human managers rather than the same $10 Billion be split between tech giants and shareholders, but it's still funny)

Upper management and middle management are the same picture.

All members of management don't do the actual work and the only reason for their existence is to try to get the actual workers to do more stuff for less money.

So even though we all know that their jobs would be one of the easiest to replace with an LLM, what will happen is management will attempt to replace as many workers with LLMs to justify their "more for less" existence.

The number of managers won't go down until there's not enough workers making money to buy the goods and services that the companies are selling. But by then we're all screwed.

LLMs can easily replace managers and execs over anybody else. Honestly, the first things LLMs replace are scammers. Most execs are scammers too.

No way imagine your boss being an LLM 😭 truly nightmare fuel

My SO boss is soo into LLM and I swear this bloke only fights and say the things for worst outcome of the department. He caves on stuff that he should have died on the hill but something trivial not even worth an ok he will drag out with hell fire.

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13548

LLMs respond like a sycophant because that's what CEOs expect. They expect to be surrounded by Yes Men and people who compliment them before they give feedback. That's why before you get an answer for a question, some LLMs will sometimes say "that's a great question."

You'll notice the same thing in Trump's cabinet. No one answers him directly, they provide him with a compliment before they give a response.

This feels more like a shower rant than a shower thought...

Either way, I'm here for it

I'd still rather have the useless fuckwit manager because at least they're some form of human vs a dumbass chatbot.

Gotta start at the top

My manager recently said their new AI tool does pretty much his whole job for him. I miss my last manager. Pretty sure it gets worse up the chain.

Only management would admit to having a machine do their job for them.