I really need to get through all the fics you've been recommending.
ComicalMayhem
I've never lived in a dorm myself but I have a friend that currently does, and from what I've seen it was clusters of rooms sharing a hallway and bathroom. Like, a door to a small hallway with 4 to 6 rooms and a shared bathroom, and then several of those clusters in a larger building. I also imagine there's a shared kitchen. I can ask though. The thing with bathrooms though is specifically the scene where Jaune and Ren are talking. Ren basically having nothing on but a towel either implies there's a bathroom/shower attached to the rooms and he was just getting out, or he walked from a shared shower down the hallway basically nude. In both cases though, there's the question of why he didn't get dressed right out the shower. If Jaune demanded to talk to him immediately, I guess, but if not and he just happened to get caught right after the shower, then in both cases the only thing I can assume is that he expected no one to be in the dorm and wanted to get dressed in the room, which is kind of odd to do imo. In honesty it probably doesn't matter though since it was just a gag scene.
For common areas, I imagine the rooms themselves are about as common area as it gets for each team, and outside of that it's whatever space there is on the school grounds. I also imagine the students are at least fairly accommodated; Atlas and Shade are likely pretty spartan, considering the lore behind them (I picture Atlas similar to a military academy and Shade similar to... idk, like the hidden leaf village or something), but I imagine at least Beacon students are given more freedoms and accommodations; kitchen, bed, bathrooms, AC, time off, etc. From the food fight, we can see the students are provided plenty of food of all varieties and time to eat, so I imagine Beacon is somewhat well off.
Re: Time frame. Hm that makes sense. I think I envisioned in my head that everyone who passed the initiation was taken back together in a big group, and that the commotion with Yusha getting stabbed separated everyone long enough that it made sense.
Re: Faunus. I think officially they're called Faunus, and I've mixed it up in previous chapters. I'm trying to correct for it tho, thanks for calling it out.
Lol it's ok, the doxxing comment was a joke. I don't really care if people know what state I live in.
Got another 9 work days ahead of me.
Gat damn, that is rough (´-ω-`) good luck! hope it isn't too bad.
Hey! Sorry, just getting back to this.
Re: The writers, volume 4/5. I didn't know any of that! That's pretty cool. Biggest fanfic project ever is a very apt description of the series lol. I've started FF7 but never got too deep, from what I've seen though, isn't Avalanche the good guys? I wonder why Monty would want to have a group inspired by them to be an antagonistic force. They could have just had a mafia if they wanted a mafia. Seems to be what mr. Clockwork Orange was supposed to do (Roman Torchwick). I'm also not familiar with the IRA. Since we're doxing ourselves, my Floridian education was very, very limited. Though, it makes sense what you said about them thinking about the BP. Authors write what they know, even if they're not thinking about it.
Re: Adam. Hey, my French history is even worse than yours. What you said about him becoming a really important figure makes sense though, and I think there was echoes of that in the series with Adam having huge sway over the WF at some point if I'm not mistaken. I know he kills the current leader and her guards helped with the coup. I really hope it was that Arryn was pushing the plot point instead of Miles and Kerry drawing inspiration from her breakup; I've been on the receiving end of that before and it's not very nice. Adam having ties to Raven makes sense, though, considering the masks.
Re: mussy pagnet. Holy fuck that is genius, despite the connotations.
Re: quickedit. All good, sorry it took me so long to get back.
Yeah that's definitely unpopular. I could not imagine eating everything cold, like what the fuck?
Re: The racism bit. Yeah that's fair. I very much appreciate a second set of eyes on the matter and if I do toddle in the wrong direction, absolutely call me out. Also, I don't think I ever even noticed the lions tail. Leo is such a relatively minor character imo, and was just so human-coded to me, I guess it just never registered. About V5, I mean I could also see them specifically avoiding racism in Mistral because a central plot point is Blake and the White Fang/Faunus in Menagerie, where she rallies them against Adam's ideology and brings a ton of support against the violent White Fang. The people of Menagerie essentially save Haven Academy (not really but that was supposed to be the point), so playing up racism in Mistral and Haven probably could have been very counter-productive to the story they were trying to tell. Personally I think they should have done it anyways; it would have solidified the decision the Faunus made, which was to fight for peace and equality rather than fight violence with more violence, despite the racism and hatred against them. Sort of a "be the better person" sort of idea? Idk, either way it would have made for a more nuanced and interesting plot. Regardless, all the lore outside of RWBY show itself seems to point towards Mistral and Atlas being pretty racist places, but like you said we're not actually shown it. Well, we are in Atlas but not in Mistral.
Re: the white fang and BLM. I would argue the original spirit of the white fang in lore was more like BLM or the civil rights movement. Blake's backstory says as much, with more peaceful protests until a change in leadership led took over and started more violent movements. After the leadership change, I think they're supposed to reflect the Black Panthers and freedom fighters in general, which turns more extremist due to Adam's influence. From a literary perspective though, the white fang serve a sort of generic bad guy group the audience can point at and know they're bad and the protags are good because they fight against them. Which is stupid, because there already is a generic bad guy group called the Grimm and Salem's posse.
Anyways the idea that people shouldn't respond to violence against them with violence, but rather respond with peace and diplomacy, is a persistent theme in lots of fiction. There's probably a trope for it, and maybe even a trope for the take where a wronged peoples turns towards extremism. Scar from FMA/FMAB, Magneto and his group in some Marvel universes, and Adam and the White Fang all share nuggets of this concept. The idea of a once peaceful group turning towards violence and in Adam's case, towards extremism isn't necessarily a bad idea and I can see the inspirations for it, even if the authors can't, since it leads into "cycles of violence/hatred" tropes that are very common and usually compelling if done right. The problem isn't the concept, it's the execution, which is done incredibly poorly and in bad taste. RWBY never actually addresses the systemic, social, and latent cultural racism against Faunus. Instead, and I mentioned this earlier, they just use the white fang as generic bad guys with no nuance or substance, just, "hey they're evil, go kill them and beat them up and stuff because you're good and they're bad." They amount to little more than generic terrorists with a spicy twist. Hell, the only reason Blake was able to motivate the people of Menagerie to action against the white fang and towards saving Haven academy is because the white fang attacked Blake's father / their leader. That one win was tantamount in the narrative to defeating racism as a whole in Mistral. Like, "oh the faunus aren't that bad because they stopped other faunus from blowing up our local university". This actually happens a lot in fictions as well, where a bad guy with a good point is exaggerated or does stupid plain evil things solely to deflect audiences from realizing that the bad guy actually has a point and might be in the right here and thus sympathizing with them or seeing the protag as evil or bad or even just less good. As much as I love Christopher Nolan's Batman, Bane is an excellent example of this, and so is Adam. I would argue the White Fang have a point and imo are justified in violent action. They've been scuffed for a long time and made little progress through peaceful protests, and as much as people love to say violence is never the answer, well... *gestures vaguely at history*. The french revolution, the american revolution, the civil war, Luigi Mangione, hell some historians believe the civil rights movement wouldn't have worked without the Black Panthers also existing as the alternative to peaceful protests. Sometimes the threat of violence or violence itself is in fact, necessary for actionable change. Except, again, RWBY doesn't address that. They don't address anything with faunus, it's a superficial analogy of real life racism and discrimination against black people and they don't even have actual black people in the story. At least, not until Flint Coal, and he's basically a token. JK Rowling ass name, fuck. The authors of RWBY have absolutely no idea how to handle racism and related themes in a meaningful way and probably weren't even really thinking about it until volume 5 and even then they just have the one and done plot point with Haven academy and then a handful of "hey everyone remember humans don't like faunus?" and "don't do racism, its bad!" moments in future volumes. Hell, do the White Fang even show up after V5? I'm pretty sure it's just Adam at that point and there's no mention of them, but you're more familiar with the lore than I am.
Ahem.
Re: everything else. Take your time reading! I get being busy and you just reading it at all is always appreciated. And that's fair about the character thing lol.
Re: Everyone clapped. Eh, sounding sarcastic is fine by me, I don't have any particular intentions with it.
Re: Infirmary. I suppose so! I'll have to change that.
Re: Orange esque. I have no idea what i was cooking with that. You're entirely right here.
Re: White long coat. Hm, I could see it breaking the adjective order but it still reads fine to me cuz "long coat" feels like one word to me. Hmmmm. White long coat vs long white coat. I'll have to sit on that one.
Re: racism in mistral. I'm pretty sure in After the Fall, it's revealed that Team CVFY explicitly chose to go to Vacuo instead of Mistral because of the racism part. Also, according to Haven Academy wiki page (of dubious authority though), Leonardo was put in Mistral by Ozpin to curb faunus racism. Also, Leo's a faunus?! I had no idea, I genuinely thought he was a human. Either way I like the idea of playing up the racism in both Haven and Mistral as a whole, since it opens plot points and I have plans in that direction. Also because I'm an egoist and think I can handle racism better than the RWBY authors.
Re: lampshades. I would say I never promised a serious story, but internally I think that's just deflection on any flaws and tone breaks, because in fairness I have pretty much been writing a serious story. That said, I'm going to tap the sign anyways because fuck it. Anyway J'atoh is fundamentally an unserious character and basically an author self insert.
Re: Haru falling asleep. Well, I mean, she does in fact fall asleep right there. She woke up resting her head on Yusha in Yusha's perspective, this is just how it happened. In any regard, there was nothing else for them to really discuss.
Re: stab. Typo, thanks for catching.
Re: last paragraph. Yep! This is in fact Haru and J'atoh's perspective of the same interaction from last chapter. I'm playing with the idea of perspectives limiting information the reader would have, though I don't think it panned out good here. How do you think I could make the scene more clear that it's the same one from previously?
This does not count as NSFW because of the shirt. Screw censorship! ヽ(>∀<☆)ノ
Me! I love rain! Rain and tea and thunder and a tin roof!
The art style is incredibly adorable.
Ok wait why is this kinda hot though?