Reddit

I got a site wide permaban for saying Putin should be executed for war crimes.

On r/ukraine

I got a 3 day ban for a really innocuous comment. Done by "AI", of course... I was so annoyed that I didn't even appeal it and just deleted my account. Should have done it way before, of course. Haven't been back in 3 weeks. All I said was that Elron Musk hates poor people, and their shit AI said that was threatening harm to someone. Okay.

Got my 7yo account banned for not verifying my mail.

Created a few more accounts with temporary mails, got banned by 'unauthentic activity'. Then I gave up all and begun to use lemmy. I try to interact on everything to create engagement

I got banned - after 13 years - for reporting hate speech.

Turns out that is “report abuse”.

Hi, welcome! Sooooo, maybe this is new info. Maybe this you already know. Either way, as a Lemmy newbie, allow me to fill you in on some lingo and details around here.

So, subreddits are called communities, but it's the same thing.

What's not the same is the core functionality. Lemmy has potentially an infinate amount of servers. I say potentially because you can start your own Lemmy server right now.

These servers are called "instances". It's just a server where you can host your own lemmy account, or your own communities.

So, you can do whatever you want on your instance. You can tell all your friends to join your instance. I could sign up for an account and be hosted by your instance.

Now I'm not saying you need to do that, or even that you should do that. I'm just saying you can. It's possible.

Now, let's talk federation.

Think of each instance as a circle. Now imagine a line connecting two circles. That connection between the two circles means they are "federated", or connected. You as a user on an instance can interact with all other federated instances. This is why you'll see topics on lemmy.world and users hosted lemmy.ml.

Lemmy.world and Lemmy.ml are two different instances, but they are federated. So Lemmy.ml users can interact with Lemmy.world communities/topics/users.

Your instance is ani.social. I'm not firmiliar with which instances you're federated with. Clearly federated with Lemmy.World.

But imagine you found a problematic instance. Like what if you found somethink like nazis.online for an instance. You might want to cut ties with them.

So now imagine that line between ani.social and nazis.online is cut. You don't want to talk to nazis, and neither does anyone on your instance. So ani.social defederates from nazis.online, and now the nazis can't see, nor interact with you, or any communities on your instance.

However, user@nazis.online can still ineract with Lemmy.ml, and ani.social can still interact with lemmy.ml. So you still may see users on other instances that you're both federated with. In that case, you can block user@nazis.online.

And Lemmy.World, and Lemmy.ml are both Lemmy. But you may see users from an instance called piefed. What is piefed? Well it's a totally different service, with its own instances, with its own communities, run by different people that can still federate with Lemmy and other instances within the fediverse. But how is this possible?

Well, the fediverse is all services that use something called activitypub. Now, I'm a bit out my own element in knowing the finer details, but the over simplified version is that if a service uses activitypub, it CAN be part of the fediverse. I say "can" because I've been told that bluesky does run activitypub, but they choose to limit their own federation to just bsky.app. Meaning there are no other bluesky instances, and no other service is federated with bluesky, even though they totally could federate with mastodon.

Bluesky is almost a 1:1 carbon copy of pre-musk twitter. Mastodon is more pre-musk twitter inspired, but also fully part of the fediverse.

Bluesky has limited interaction with mastodon. I've never tried it, despite having both a bluesky and mastodon account. I've heard you need to bridge the accounts, and it's a whole thing. So I never bothered. I hear it's clumsy, and not worth it.

And there's a whole bunch of fediverse services.

Lemmy/piefed are like reddit.

Peertube is like youtube.

Loops is like tiktok.

Pixelfed is like instagram.

Friendica is like facebook.

And when I say all this, there's one giant elephant in the room we haven't addressed yet. Corporate interests.

Lets say you're still on X for some god awful reason. Well, you probably notice that they push their own agenda on you. They make money by getting you to follow the agenda. On the fediverse, there are no owners.

Like I said earlier, you can run your own instance. If Sony wanted to advertise on Lemmy, it would be damn near impossible. Because they could advertise on Lemmy.World, but only Lemmy.World users would see the ad. Because when you interact with Lemmy.World, you personally are not on Lemmy.World. You're on Lemmy.World via Ani.social. So you're actually browsing all this from Ani.Social. You never actually leave there. And if you try to go directly to Lemmy.World, you'll find you're not logged in. Because they have no login credentials for you. But if you go back to Ani.Social, you'll find things just as you left them. Still able to interact with Lemmy.World but still technically browsing Lemmy.World via Ani.Social.

I know thats a lot to throw at a newbie, but I promise it's only complicated in the begining. Once you get it, it's like second nature.

One last thing, despite being called the "fediverse", there's no need to worry. It has nothing to do with Kevin Federline.

I got a 2 month ban on worldnews in a thread about Tesla stocks going to shit and Elon Musk crying about it. My comment was "Hahaha, may he suffer" and apparently that is harassment and inciting violence.

Here by choice not by force. I left Reddit when they chose to fuck up by abandoning the API for Ads. Haven't missed Reddit one bit. If you aren't already, you'll be happy somewhere in the federation. Sorry about losing history, hopefully you are okay with your transition to the future.

AI mods, and increasingly AI content, they're making it a training ground for what they can get away.

It will become more like Facebook.

I had to go shortly after the "He gets us" Jesus ads made their appearance.

Two weeks shy of 15 years and got permabaned last October.. Sniped by a bot. Oh well. Found old.lemmy.zip a few days later, signed up and learned how to sub to the communities on other instances and have never looked back.

Am not even angry about it anymore, since it's waaay more laid back and chill here. Like Reddit was before 2012 or so.. Do a lot more reading, which has brought my game up and also, no rage-bots.. so that alone is pure delight.

Welcome to the party, it's low-key but once you find your groove, and learn to sub across the various instances.. it's a blast!

Can't wait for the day Reddit advertisers finally realize they're advertising mostly to bots. I'm building up my stockpile of popcorn to watch the shitshow.

Dude, I feel you. Welcome from a fellow Reddit expat. Right after the Inauguration, Musk had a meeting with Spez, and they permabanned an unknown, but enormous number of people, including me, with a 12 year account, and a million Karma.

People like you and me were on Reddit when NOBODY knew who they were. We BUILT that site, made it the active conversational free speech site it was supposed to be, until they started getting heavy handed, and then went full MAGA for the second round.

You'll find Lemmy is a LOT more forgiving for political speech, although some instances and subs still have some stupid mods.

There aren't nearly as many niche forums as Reddit, which is too bad, and there isn't nearly as much engagement. You won't be getting thousands, or even hundreds of upvotes. Dozens, maybe. Often none.

On the other hand, you don't get anywhere near the amount of nonsense you have to put up with at Reddit. The other day I checked out a post that came up in a search, and had to bail because I couldn't get through the dozens and dozens of pun posts, totally irrelevant tangents, bots, novelty accounts, etc. I never did reach any actual conversation about the subject. It was so much worse than 18 months ago, and it was already bad then.

MAGA has obviously discovered the power of Reddit, and destroyed it. They haven't found Lemmy yet.

Welcome aboard!

Right after Melon Husk bought Twitter, I posted something about Howard Schultz (CEO of Starbucks) while he was questioned about his anti-union activities in front of Congress. I wanted to slap the smile off his face into next Tuesday. That got me a 7 day ban. I didn't log in for a month. When I came back, my feed was just as nasty. I moved everyone I followed to Mastodon if they had an account. Same with Facebook. That was over 2 years ago. When BlueSky started using their posts for LLMs, I deleted my account.

Mom told me this story about a little old man that a reporter saw praying against the Western Wall (of the original Temple) in Jerusalem. The man was there for over a week during the morning and afternoons. The reporter wanted some insight into this man's devotion, so he asked him about it.

The old man pondered the question then said "In the mornings, I come and pray for peace. Then I have a bit of a nosh and come back in the afternoon I pray again for peace."

"Well, given what's happening right now, what's that like?" asked the reporter.

"It's like talking to a wall." said the old man sadly.

individual sub bans for simply joining other subs

This is nucking futs.

Welcome. Get ready to realize just how dogshit reddit is (both the userbase and the policies). Try to let go of any maladaptive habits you don't need anymore (self-censoring, treating all argumenters in bad faith, or anything else you've needed to do to survive reddit); this is an opportunity to start anew.

I lost my 11y account for the audacity of song lyrics that a random mod classed as hate speech. It had a rude word 😑.

Fuck them. It's thankfully more authentic here and a lot less bots. I've yet to see a haiku.

Welcome to the real world, Neo.

I had a reddit alt that disappeared for what seemed like 2 years, then all of a sudden I was able to find it and access it again. 🤔 I stopped posting over there around the time of the API blackout and now I have a whole process of sites I go through before I cave and check if something is on reddit.

My perma ban was liking a comment. Turns out that goes against rule 1.

It was a comment making fun if R1 under a security video of a therapist abusing an autistic child.

Greetings! Hope you like your stay!

If you'd like to also explore options, there's Mastodon for followinf Twitter-like posts (and also PixelFed, NeoDB, WordPress, etc.), Friendica and Mbin for following both Twitter and Reddit-like posts, and PieFed as a direct alternative to Lemmy specifically.

And tip, Lemmy has a native per-post, post-hiding feature, at the 3 dots of a given post. Mastodon has too, and most softwares I've tested work well with Ublock Origin filters and/or scripts for hiding posts (e.g. if liked/disliked).

I also had a 12 year account that got banned. I do miss some of the more specialized subs, but I enjoy the casual scrolling here.

I am not YET permanently banned on Reddit, even though I have been temporarily banned a few times. I am moving away to PieFed though... but I find it difficult to get engagement without the ability to have crossposts link back to the main post. I am just sick of Reddit and their behaviour. They arbitrarily ban people and then refuse to ban literal terrorists and people who keeps going on mass-shootings were radicalised on Reddit, which got them investigated by the Department of Justice BOTH back during the Biden-era and the current Trump-era. I may often not agree with the Threadiverse politically and get into my fair share of debates (I have an older account that I cannot find on Lemmy that I made in 2023- but whatever since I like PieFed more), but Reddit is just THAT BAD where they somehow make both the left and right investigate them. Bruh. They are just dogwater, which is an insult to dogwater. 😭

The API price increase and Apollo shutting down was my breaking point with Reddit.

Welcome aboard! About a year ago my 11 year old Reddit account was banned. I don't even know why I was banned since I'd lost access to the email account I used to create the account long ago. For a day or two I was just really confused why I couldn't log in anymore.

Oh well, Reddit had been on a down hill trajectory for a while, but I do miss some of the smaller niche subreddits I used to frequent. We'll eventually have communities like that as Lemmy, PieFed, etc continues to grow.

Shame you didn't get banned for exposing a pedo ring. Yes they call that one harassment

At least I feel I'm not engaging with endless bots here

I'm not banned but I haven't participated much there for a couple of years.

I've heard that Fediverse wasn't much better, but the fact that Lemmy, Piefed, Mastodon and pretty much any other Fediverse platform are open source, and completely ridden of ads, and data collection from giant corporations is already a HUGE difference.

Sure people are just people and you're gonna find toxic communities everywhere, but at least here you don't need to "fear" getting banned because you can choose an instance that has core principles you share, and through them you can access pretty much any community you want, and keep active.

On Reddit, you have no other place to go. You either shut the fuck up and accept their terms, or you, if you get banned, there's nothing you can do about it.

Also, a lot of communities here in Lemmy/Piefed are very active. I don't need to be drowned on an infinity number of posts when most of them are just silly repetitive memes or karma whoring.

I hope you already edited all of your comments and posts

Yeah, fuck them. My account over there is a bit older than yours was and it's been hit with 2 3 day bans recently for "threatening violence" for posts which clearly were not threatening violence. I hope they were by bots, because God save us all if real people with reading comprehension at that level have been given authority of any kind. They don't pay any attention to the appeals so I just insulted the admin staff in the last one.