The thing I remember most about the early internet was staking out your own weird little corners. There wasn't much of any "everything" site yet, so you'd find the things that appealed to you and settle there.
A lot of my early tastes in indie and experimental music were formed by the Music message board on GameFAQs. I was already going there for the walkthroughs and found my way to some of the under-populated, miscellaneous boards.
You experienced meeting people with names (even if just pseudonyms) and ideas that weren't just blended into an algorithmic slurry.
It's why I like Lemmy, I can feel a bit of that here. Still, I have a hard time surrendering things like Twitter and moved instantly to Bluesky where I continue the trend ...