this post was submitted on 28 Jan 2025
13 points (100.0% liked)
NZ Politics
576 readers
67 users here now
Kia ora and welcome to the NZ Politics community!
This is a place for respectful discussions about everything that's political and kiwi
This is an inclusive space where diverse opinions are valued, but please don't be a dick
Banner image by Tom Ackroyd, CC-BY-SA
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Not local, so feel free to ignore me.
There are more reasons I don't like speed limits, but here are the three that annoy me the most:
Taking away personal resposibility - somehow speed has become the single measure of everything. Here in UK you can have 3 pints and still be under the legal limit to drive, so hey - as long as you're not going over the arbitrary speed limit - you're all good! You also don't need to take care of your car, nor actually know how to drive; or respect any other traffic rules. As long as you're not speeding!
Driving at low speeds is boring. It creates an illusion that one has enough mental capacity to handle a phone call, a text, a youtube video, a netflix show, etc. It's easier to zone out. Maybe boring is not the perfect word for this - I'm looking for the inverse of involving.
Speeding fines have become a source of revenue. If speeding was genuinely as horrible as it's painted in all the marketing - punishment would be taking away the ability to drive, not some money.
My 2 pence.
Perhaps I am misunderstanding your point, but if someone crashes into me at high speed and maims me, I don't think knowing it was their "personal responsibility" would make me feel any better about it.
It's worth noting the reason for the speed limit changes. Physics.
Many countries (apparently not the UK) have been adopting a Vision Zero style policy, that originated in Sweden some decades ago. The idea is to have a multifaceted approach with an overarching believe than no one should die just travelling from one place to another.
To do this, you look at why people die. We have already introduced a lower alcohol limit and (controversial) drug driving checks. But one of the tenets of Vision Zero is accepting that people are human. Personal responsibility sure, but crashes very often involve innocent parties. When a drunk driver drives off the road and kills a pedestrian, we don't say that pedestrian shouldn't have been walking on the footpath.
So Vision Zero (I've called it this in my comment but in NZ it was branded "Road to zero") says if people are going to crash, what can we do about it? What we want to do is reduce the consequences. We put up dividing barriers so if you drift over the centre line you aren't going to drive into oncoming traffic. We put up barriers along the sides in higher risk areas. We try to make our roads straighter, flatter, wider, more boring. And also what we do is we reduce speed limits. A crash releases double the energy at 120kph as one at 80kph does.
And as a final note, if you want driving to be exciting, please keep it to the race track. While reducing speed limits is (mostly) not about reducing crashes caused by speed, there are crashes caused by speed, and too often they are from people being dicks driving like it's a race track.
Just in case you've not driven in NZ before - I figured it might be worth sharing footage of one of the roads where the speed limit is being increased by 25% as a bit of context. Coming from the UK you'll understand how our rural roads can be narrow & windy, but maybe its different where our main roads are only a bit upgraded from that?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pez0z3VquvI
It was reduced from 100 -> 80km/h on the steep and windy parts because its very remote so accidents in this area are difficult to respond to. The weather conditions over the road can also be quite challenging a sit gets snow & ice closures and given its height going over a dividing range can get very wet with visibility difficulties due to low cloud cover. Because so much of it is very steep, or very windy, or both there are a lot of vehicles that through this stretch can almost never do 80km/h, especially during holiday times with the number of boats and caravans traversing it.
Its also quite a busy road as its the primary route North-South out of the Hawkes Bay a relatively populated area, and even though its only single lane each direction it counts as one of our main state highways.
I've driven it plenty of times when it was 100km/h, and then when it was reduced to 80km/h and the difference in total time over the road really feels pretty negligible. The main reason for ending up going slower than you want over it is when you can't take advantage of a freight truck or campervan pulling into a slow bay because there's already a line of 30 cars trying to get past and then you have to wait another couple of kms until the next opportunity. At those points you're often doing barely 50km/h anyway.