Five bucks says that the guy who didn't vote for Ichiro didn't hand out 10 votes, and that the snub is purely because they don't believe anyone should be unanimous.
this post was submitted on 21 Jan 2025
9 points (84.6% liked)
Baseball
761 readers
8 users here now
The fans' home for baseball.
Mods wanted!
If you’re a member of the original mod team for r/baseball (or just wish to help out in general), DM @headie_sage@fanaticus.social and I’ll restore your position :)
AL East
!tampabayrays@fanaticus.social !orioles@fanaticus.social !nyyankees@fanaticus.social !torontobluejays@fanaticus.social !redsox@fanaticus.social
AL Central
!minnesotatwins@fanaticus.social !clevelandguardians@fanaticus.social !whitesox@fanaticus.social !motorcitykitties@fanaticus.social !kcroyals@fanaticus.social
AL West
!texasrangers@fanaticus.social !astros@fanaticus.social !angelsbaseball@fanaticus.social !mariners@fanaticus.social !oaklandathletics@fanaticus.social
NL East
!braves@fanaticus.social !miamimarlins@fanaticus.social !phillies@fanaticus.social !newyorkmets@fanaticus.social !nationals@fanaticus.social
NL Central
!buccos@fanaticus.social !brewers@fanaticus.social !reds@fanaticus.social !chicubs@fanaticus.social !cardinals@fanaticus.social
NL West
!azdiamondbacks@fanaticus.social !sfgiants@fanaticus.social !dodgers@fanaticus.social !padres@fanaticus.social !coloradorockies@fanaticus.social
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
CC was already a HoFer in my heart. Didn't know his stats stacked up so well against other lefty starters already in the hall though. Don't think we'll see another 3k strikeout pitcher for a while, if ever.
All great inductees. Ichiro was a machine and I can’t believe someone didn’t vote for him.
Wagner was off my radar, but just based on stats I'm not super impressed? Like, I understand relievers aren't held to the same standard as SPs, and a 2.3 career ERA is damn good... But half as much bWAR as Mariano? How is that not Hall of Very Good material?
Like Adam Wainwright, who won't even whiff the hall, provided more WAR in half the games just by eating innings...
He’s 8th in overall career saves. That’s pretty elite.
Fair enough. I'm not really a fan of saves as a stat, like wins they seem a bit too arbitrary/contextual vs. actually measuring the outcome of pitching, but I'm also not a small hall type so sure.