I doubt that would work. If history is to be of any indication then Palestinians also have no desire to co-exist with Israel. If the sides were reversed Palestine would be doing the exact same things as Israel is doing. Arabs want Israel gone and it's been clear since the state of Israel was officially founded in 1948.

Just take all the Israelis out of that region and give them Ohio.

This. Israel never should have been there in the first place. It’s stolen land, ruled by a tyrannical apartheid regime.