this post was submitted on 25 Jan 2026
29 points (91.4% liked)
movies
3002 readers
340 users here now
A community about movies and cinema.
Related communities:
- !television@piefed.social
- !homevideo@feddit.uk
- !mediareviews@lemmy.world
- !casualconversation@piefed.social
Rules
- Be civil
- No discrimination or prejudice of any kind
- Do not spam
- Stay on topic
- These rules will evolve as this community grows
No posts or comments will be removed without an explanation from mods.
founded 11 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The only one that felt like Trek was the one written by an actual Trek fan and generally talented storyteller, Simon Pegg.
And agree with other comments that the cast was really good. Just had horrible stories and mediocre (at best) direction.
You can tell that knowing the source material on franchise movies matters: I couldn't stand JJ's Trek but I really liked Ep7. (Ep 9 was decent, but things were so off the rails after ep 8 there wasn't much to recover)
Unfortunately Pegg was brought in to write it once they were deep into filming so he really had no chance.
I have never understood the notion that it was the only one that felt like a Star Trek movie, none of it made any sense.
Why was Kirk navel gazing about being captain?
Why did the bad guys wait on the planet when they had a working starship..
Destroying The Enterprise is Terry?
To me it felt more like Trek because it was at least occasionally philosophical and moralistic. Not just a stop-the-terrorist action movie.
It was fast from a perfect film though, don't get me wrong. Plot holes and idiot plots. I'd still choose to watch a lot of other stuff before it. But it's middle of the pack for Trek overall, IMO. Still beats ST: 3, Insurrection, Nemesis, etc