Closed source? Immediately zero trust.
Privacy
A community for Lemmy users interested in privacy
Rules:
- Be civil
- No spam posting
- Keep posts on-topic
- No trolling
You're not gonna trust some rando on the internet with your sensitive data? You're crazy!
Fair. Want to build a bit of recognition first, then it all opens at 300, it's on the roadmap. Honestly til then I'd treat it as alias and disposable mail more than your main inbox. Once it's open and audited you can verify all of it yourself
I would not use a service where the operator is not clearing declaring their legal identity and corp contact info and registered business address.
I have no way to know who you are or why you are doing this and I can think of a lot of reasons someone who do this that are not in my interest.
cool. cool. just get back to us when you get to that point on the roadmap then. Nothing will give you better input into holes than gpl.
Unless I know you personally and your qualifications to build this, nothing would make me use or trust it.
Haha, I chuckle at everyone shitting on it already like they've never used A Gmail, hotmail, or icloud account who are way worse than what you're stating.
Plus, it's a test, you're not asking people to migrate their whole lives to it.
Anyway, as an up-and-coming service/provider, its nice to see competition in this space. I do have a few questions:
- Why currently closed source and not launching with open source? You're eventually going that way anyway, right?
- If its owned hardware and not everything on 1 box, but you'd make no money, how are you going to fund projects in the future? What about upgrades or unforeseen expenses?
- What's your end goal making your own over Proton, Tuta, etc? Are there newer/better encryption methods? Is this a project to learn from?
- If its owned hardware and not everything on 1 box, but you'd make no money, how are you going to fund projects in the future? What about upgrades or unforeseen expenses?
They could start taking donations, but it is worth asking the question to get them thinking about future plans
Apreciate this, genuinely.
- Opening it at 11 users does nothing, nobody audits a nobody. Want a bit of recognition first, and honestly want it rock solid before the whole internet tears into it. Opens at 300, that's the deal.
- Fair one. "No money" means no ads, no data selling, no investors, not zero revenue ever. It's cheap to run now and I cover it myself. As it grows: donations first, then paying for capacity like storage and extra aliases, anonymous payment. Never charging for privacy itself.
- Honestly, we want to be real competition, not just another inbox. The goal is a full private cloud: mail, messaging and drive on the same keys, with real anonymity built in. Crypto itself is standard (OpenPGP, curve25519, Argon2), the bet is the honesty and the full anonymous stack, not fancier math. We're 11 users and a long way off, so judge the steps not the dream.
Thanks for the quick reply. Looks like you're at 12 users now on your website. Count me a 13 haha.
I'm not good at reading through the code, but I test features, function, errors, holes, etc. I'll do what I can.
Bye