this post was submitted on 07 Jan 2026
11 points (76.2% liked)

Anarchism

2703 readers
20 users here now

Discuss anarchist praxis and philosophy. Don't take yourselves too seriously.


Other anarchist comms


Join the matrix room for some real-time discussion.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Rough idea made on a whim. Constructive and critical feedback welcome. Better memes depicting the idea even more welcome.

Image: A gloved hand peeling an Anarchy sticker off Malarchy.

Text: Malarchy masquerades as Anarchy, to look good, and make Anarchy look bad.

For one real world example among many, to consider stop falling for: Those palates of bricks that big money conveniently deliver to bank/capitalism protests.

Heh, I wonder how "over the target" this is, and gets heavily downvoted by agents and unwitting assets not liking the reveal or invite to scrutiny. ;)

[Edit: Since "Malarchy"'s not nearly as well known or as immediately understood as I imagined,

Mal-Archy, is a bit of a portmanteau made of:

mal

    1. Evil; disease.
    1. A prefix of Latin origin, through French (equivalent to dys- or caco- of Greek origin), meaning ‘bad,’ and implying usually imperfection or deficiency, and often simply a negative, as in malodor, a bad odor, malfeasance, bad- or wrong-doing, malformation, imperfect shape, maladroit, not adroit, malcontent, not content, etc. The prefix in this form occurs only in words taken from the French, or formed upon the analogies of such.

&

archy

    1. A suffix properly meaning a rule, ruling, as in monarchy, the rule of one only. Cf. -arch.

Archy, ruled by.

Mal, bad.

And it's like "Malarkey", deceptive foolishness too. But with more dominating unjust power overtones.

Malarchy. ]

PS, While I'm at it... Some relevant quotes:

"Governments have always used the pretext of ‘public safety’ to suppress dissent. They create the very chaos they claim to fight, so they can pose as saviors." -- Errico Malatesta

"The history of the State is the history of violence, but it is also the history of lies—lies told to the people to make them accept their own enslavement." -- Peter Kropotkin

"Every act of government violence is wrapped in the flag and sold as patriotism. The State’s greatest trick is making people believe that their oppressors are their protectors." -- Emma Goldman

"States don’t just respond to crises—they need crises. They need enemies, real or invented, to justify their existence. The ‘war on terror’ is just the latest version of a very old game." -- David Graeber

"The first revolutionist is the State itself. It revolts against its own principles, against its own lies, to better enslave us under new disguises." -- Mikhail Bakunin

"The most effective way to neutralize a radical idea is to take its symbols, drain them of meaning, and sell them back to the people as a commodity." -- David Graeber

"The worst enemies of anarchy are not its open opponents, but those who pretend to be anarchists while serving the interests of the powerful." -- Errico Malatesta

"Beware those who wrap themselves in the red flag to hide their betrayal." -- Gustave Lefrançais

"They fear our ideas, so they steal our symbols." -- Anonymous

"The State’s favorite anarchist is a fake one."

"Real anarchy threatens power. Fake anarchy is power."

"They wear our symbols like costumes… but their script is written by the State

"The State is nothing but a vast machine for the oppression of the masses, a machine that lives on lies and thrives on the ignorance of the people." -- Mikhail Bakunin

"Fascism and capitalism are not opposites—they are partners in the same crime. One gives the orders, the other provides the guns. Both rely on your fear, your confusion, and your obedience. Do not believe their lies. Do not obey their commands. Think for yourself, act for yourself, and trust only in solidarity." -- Errico Malatesta

[Edit: oh... I already added this to the end too... Why was that other responder requesting... "You can post 10000 quotes but not just tell us what you mean with “Malarchy”? "Oh... their intention was on the "just"... as in to rid the quotes... no wait, but why did they also say I can add 10,000 quotes... I'm very confused... their answer was already there... why were they~ ugh, never mind. Well, it's now added above as well as beneath the anarchists' quotes depicting malarchy; power/archy's deceitfulness. Surely there wont be a third responder asking what's malarchy now, since that's been well covered here at least 3 or 4 times now. Unless they're just up to more malarchy.]

mal noun

Evil; disease. A prefix of Latin origin, through French (equivalent to dys- or caco- of Greek origin), meaning ‘bad,’ and implying usually imperfection or deficiency, and often simply a negative, as in malodor, a bad odor, malfeasance, bad- or wrong-doing, malformation, imperfect shape, maladroit, not adroit, malcontent, not content, etc. The prefix in this form occurs only in words taken from the French, or formed upon the analogies of such. (Oh, I did not know that… “The prefix in this form occurs only in words taken from the French, or formed upon the analogies of such.” Interesting. And I dare say, fitting, what with all the revolutionary spirit in France.)

&

archy adjective

Arched. archy brows A suffix properly meaning a rule, ruling, as in monarchy, the rule of one only. Cf. -arch. Archy, ruled by.

Mal, bad.

top 10 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] alzymologist@sopuli.xyz 5 points 2 weeks ago (1 children)

Malarchy extermination squad is coming to you for masquerade violation!

[–] Digit@lemmy.wtf 3 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago)

They've already been. ~~8~~ 9 times. I am still here.

[–] Tiempo@lemmy.dbzer0.com 3 points 2 weeks ago (1 children)
[–] Digit@lemmy.wtf 0 points 2 weeks ago (1 children)

What is what?

Can you clarify what you're seeking clarification on?

I thought I was thorough in the accompanying text, so I could use some help to know what you're asking about that was not already/adequately covered.

[–] Tiempo@lemmy.dbzer0.com 4 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago) (1 children)

Malarchy. I had never heard the word before and after some DDG-Fu I couldn't find an answer that made sense to me (related to the meme) My first language isn't English so maybe I'm missing something or the word for the same thing is another in Spanish, I don't know

[–] Digit@lemmy.wtf 0 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago)

Ah, thanks. Happy to expand on that.

Malarchy, I suppose is a bit of a portmanteau^1^ neologism^2^.

https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=malarchy offers us

malarchy

mal-ark-ee

Something that generates a lot of work or fuss.

"I can't be bothered with all that malarchy."

or "Organising this was such a malarchy!"

or "This organising malarchy isn't easy."

by Rabid Giraffe May 24, 2006

or

malarchy

Word orgin: prefix "mal" meanining inappropriate or askew as in "malpractice", "archy" meaning "form of rule" or > "governing body" as in monarchy.

Definition:1) action resulting from foolish judgement.

  1. Foolish statement.
  • That statement is malarchy.
  • That malarchy kept me sweeping up shadows all day.

by koafancypants September 19, 2007

There is also the word "malarkey",

malarkey

/mə-lär′kē/

noun

Exaggerated or foolish talk, usually intended to deceive.

But I like koafancypants's definition of malarchy better.

mal, as in malice, malicious, malfeasance, malefic, maladaption etc.

archy as in ruler, ruled by, dominated by, archons, arch nemesis.

mal-archy.

malicious [& deceptive] rule/ruler/ruling [feigning offer of liberty/freedom/goodness].

Websearch on the etymology of the two parts, mal, and archy, provides me the summaries:

mal noun

  1. Evil; disease.
  2. A prefix of Latin origin, through French (equivalent to dys- or caco- of Greek origin), meaning ‘bad,’ and implying usually imperfection or deficiency, and often simply a negative, as in malodor, a bad odor, malfeasance, bad- or wrong-doing, malformation, imperfect shape, maladroit, not adroit, malcontent, not content, etc. The prefix in this form occurs only in words taken from the French, or formed upon the analogies of such.

(Oh, I did not know that... "The prefix in this form occurs only in words taken from the French, or formed upon the analogies of such." Interesting. And I dare say, fitting, what with all the revolutionary spirit in France.)

&

archy adjective

  1. Arched. archy brows
  2. A suffix properly meaning a rule, ruling, as in monarchy, the rule of one only. Cf. -arch.

Archy, ruled by.

Mal, bad.

And that it's typically pronounced phonetically identical to malarkey, the foolishness and lies are also highlighted in malarchy.

I hope that wasn't too long, and helps.

^1^ Portmanteau. Here are a couple relevant definitions of portmanteau I copied from websearch summary blurb

  • A word formed by merging the sounds and meanings of two different words, as chortle, from chuckle and snort."
  • A word or part of a word that is analyzable as consisting of more than one morpheme without a clear boundary between them, as French du “of the” from de “of” and le “the.”

^2^ Neologism. Here's the relevant definition copied from websearch summary blurb:

  • A new word, expression, or usage.
[–] Uiop@lemmy.dbzer0.com 1 points 2 weeks ago (1 children)

But a sticker over another sticker in the real world is sort of like a grafitti over another. The second person disagrees with the first person and wants their own message to superimpose and drown out whatever was originally there.

You can post 10000 quotes but not just tell us what you mean with "Malarchy"?

[–] Digit@lemmy.wtf 1 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago) (1 children)

But a sticker over another sticker in the real world is sort of like a grafitti over another. The second person disagrees with the first person and wants their own message to superimpose and drown out whatever was originally there.

Good critique. Thanks.

I hadn't quite thought of it like that.

Would need to be [obviously not mere malarchy propaganda sticker but] a character of pure malarchy, and an anarchist pulling of the false label, more obviously as a reveal. As is, could be mistaken for someone preferring to remove anarchist propaganda/symbology in favour of malarchy propaganda. I had worried as is (without the glue pealing away with it ~ that I lazily neglected to draw) it could look like the anarchist label being put over the malarchy, which in the sense of your critique would kinda still work as a positive, but not the same message of warning about malarchy masquerading as anarchy.

Yeah, needs more of a "They Live" reveal vibe. ... Oooh, could just straight up copy the glasses removal meme from They Live.

Yep. Room for improvement on the initial scribbled idea. Thanks for the reply.

You can post 10000 quotes but not just tell us what you mean with “Malarchy”?

See the other reply for an elaboration on the etymology and definitions... or for a tl;dr: Mal-Archy.

I'll edit in a little bit to the OP, since it's not as immediately obvious to all as I imagined.

[Edit: Oh, sorry, I misread/misinterpreted that as a request to provide what "Malarchy" means... was that a suggestion to rid the relevant quotes depicting Malarchy? In hindsight, after seeing I had (forgot I) already edited in the meaning of malarchy after the other reply from someone who didn't get it, I got perplexed at what you were saying... Did the quotes not strike as obviously relevantly depicting malarchy?]

[–] Uiop@lemmy.dbzer0.com 1 points 2 weeks ago (1 children)

I think I wrote my comment before you edited your post, but still i do not quite understand what malarchy means.

Etymology says: "bad" & "rule", so is it bad to rule, bad rulings, bad rulers...

You also hinted on deception by the rulers being a core point of this thing you are trying to establish.

"My 10000 quotes but no explanation" is perhaps a bit mean. Im not gonna sugarcoat it and just say it straight: Part 1) i dont like you using big words and not defining big words clearly. That is the essence of any thinker establishing a new idea, they are able to provide a new interpretation, a new concept with wings to fly. You however have taken malarky as a metaphorical chicklet (concept) and set it before the metaphorical wolf (collective consiousness / public / critics & importantly people who have never heard of or even thought of what you mean with malarchy.)

Part 2) some big-dicked philosopher has said a sentence once. Now what? You know the sentence? "A good quote can speak a thousand words, when embedded in a thousand words saying the same thing" - me

You need to embed quotes in context, who was the speaker? Marx, no need to define it, Kropotkin maybe a bit. Errico Malatesta? David Graebor? Sorry to show off my unknowing, but i have no-idea who these people are or could be, i dont know what they stand for, what or who they are relevant to...

For all i know they could be a monkey in a trenchcoat with a Hakenkreuz typing random wordstrings on a typewriter. Yes i presume it falls upon me to need to do work and learn about these people... But its much easier to not do this, to not spend the effort to just forget about this whole thing, delete my phone and go into the cold night all alone.

Back to my quote, you need to make a quote and the text live together, to say the same thing, even when you are actually disproving it or going on about something different. Show how a principal established by a great big-dicjed philosopher applies to this or that case, or where they fail. Establish connection. Make it make sense. What am I talking about?

You posted a webcomic about someone uncovering the truth that someone was hiding "Malarchy" underneath Anarchy. (Like a drug den underneath a laundry washing place. -> metaphors, i forced myself to use them, until they come naturally) then you appended a bunch of quotes, because you thought they fit. But you didnt expand upon that or them. You just planted them there, and frankly i must admit, i havent even read them, i just got upset.

But on the other hand I was already confused trying to read the comic, then understanding the text, questioning whether what was said had any coherence in and of itself... But first of i had to comprehend the symbol, when I try to picture it in my mind, i see the Purple W standing for Wario with a few purple Lines thrown in. Not very memorable, but confusing.


But something scratches at the back of my brain, now after spending too much time than simple mindless scrolling would allow, i must say, there is some kind of series or other visual media where this concept was explored before. I however do not remember yet where... (Tributes of Bread maybe?)

Malarchy: An interpretation of governance where a governing bodies corruption leads it to invite harm upon its subjects, incite violence amongst them, in order to strengthen its own legitimacy or power.

Hows that for a working definition?

[–] Uiop@lemmy.dbzer0.com 1 points 2 weeks ago

Currently, as it stand the only greater cultural relevance for the word Malarchy is that it Rhymes with and sounds like a worse version of anarchism. Which is a good start. Now people need to use it instead of some other words that are forgotten in a week.