this post was submitted on 17 Mar 2026
80 points (100.0% liked)
United States | News & Politics
9053 readers
311 users here now
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The actions of "Israel" is that of a sovereign Settler-Colonial project that acts within its own interests. The US is the world hegemon of Capitalism-Imperialism and its actions are determined by its interests in participating in the global process of capital accumulation. These interests are set forth by the historical process of the development of capital into a global political and economic system.
The stability of the zionist entity's settler colonial project, like that of the early US settler-colonial project, is dependent upon
The interests of Israel are often encompassed within the interests of global capital (The US being the world hegemon of global capital). This is much the case because the destabilization of Southwest Asia and North Africa allows for the greater penetration of capital into regions that are often seen, from the Imperial Capitalist Class's perspective, as being more impermeable and whose political and economic conditions as being unfavorable for the profitable extraction of materials and the exploitation of labor. Through the process of Israel struggling to attain stability for itself through the practice of settler-colonialism, they are creating conditions that are favorable for Capitalism-Imperialism i.e. favorable for the US regime.
Here we can see how the US and Israel can share material interests. This I am sure we don't disagree on. I hope so far that I haven't given off an air of arrogance in the way I'm setting up my point, I'm just trying to lay a groundwork.
The zionist entity doesn't need to be told to genocide Gaza, bomb its neighbors, and annex territory, just as the US doesn't need to be told to help with the destabilization of Israel's neighbors, the SWANA region as a whole, and the attack on Iran. This is the case because both share material interests and these actions change geopolitical-economic conditions in a way that favor the achievement of said interests for both of them.
In reference to the relationship between the US and Israel, I said it's "ridiculous to say that the zionist entity is the real shot caller." In other words, I am saying that the US is in control of itself and has a greater control of its own power and how that power is being projected into SWANA. This is not a denial of Israel's attempts to sway US policy. Instead, we can see Israel's attempts of swaying US policy, through examples like blackmail, as proof of the US's sovereignty over its own interests and power, for if this wasn't the case than why would Israel being trying to gain leverage over the US in the first place.
For the reasons stated above the US and Israel both share the interest of seeing Iran destroyed. Iran, it's existence; resistance; and support of resistance groups throughout the region is a threat to the zionist entity's settler-colonial project. For this reason, Israel wants the destruction of Iran. Iran, its sovereignty and control of its own material resources; its unwillingness to allow western penetration into its own domestic markets; its control over strategic geography that can be leveraged against global capital (Stright of Hormuz); and the fact that, through its exercise of its sovereignty, it acts against the interests of global capital in such a way that makes it a buttress of the formation of a more multipolar world. A multipolar world that would necessitate the reduction of the US's hegemonic control and power of the global order of capitalism-imperialism. It's here that we can see that the US's war on Iran isn't just some war Israel started but is in fact a war carried out by the US for real and material purposes in order to achieve real and material interests.
As far as the US's military prestige and legitimacy being shredded, in my opinion, it is the result of several things.
Edit: Formatting Markdown
i ain't reading all that
why the fuck are you acting like it's a constant, "be trying," dawg they gained and have clearly utilized that leverage!
What is this mind fuckery doublethought where you can literally look at a probable Mossad run blackmail operation entrapping, again, the then richest man in the world (with the current richest all but begging to become a part) as well as the current U.S. president (with very probable success on others, unless you think Clinton would never), bear witness to the numerous ways Israel does not act as a vassal (bombing Gaza isn't it, but shit like attacking Iran when it's obvious how it's going to go is) and still go on telling people not to believe their lying eyes?
Is it being so afraid of people becoming antisemitic and laying all the faults of capitalism on Israel? Because if that's the case you're just going to do the exact opposite and fucking empower that by telling people to ignore the obvious
No, both their posts were solidly reasoned and well - stated, if you could be bothered.
Whelp, can't help you with that buddy ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Well, I explain it in the reply I made to you, but you didn't read it...
No. But if you want me to touch upon antisemitism, I will.
Firstly, it is not my responsibility to center the defense of Jewish people from the antisemitism that results from a fascist, Jewish-Supremacist, and Settler-Colonial project that widely uses the ideology of Islamophobia to justify its genocidal agenda. An agenda and justification that greatly benefits those who fall within the category of Jewishness in much the same way as the US agenda of settler-colonialism, justified by white-supremacy, greatly benefits those who fall within the category of whiteness. In fact, there is much to be said about the relationship between Jewish supremacy and "whiteness" inside Israel's Settler-Colonial project itself but that is beyond the point of this response. If we are to center anyone it should be the victims of Israel and the victims of US Imperialism. With this said, it is of the upmost importance, as communists and workers, to not fall into the trap of the antisemitic explanation. This is especially the case for explanations of US foreign policy.
In order to understand why there exists an antisemitic explanation that we must not fall into, we must first ask ourselves, "whose interests does it serve to not understand the motivations of US foreign policy?" The answer to this question is of course, the capitalist's interest.
Statements such as, "Israel is the senior partner of the US," "The US government is controlled by Israel," and "The US only joined the war on Iran because of Israel" are incorrect and are not grounded in a material understanding of the world. Furthermore, the logical progression of these statements leads us to the same idealist worldview that is held by the reactionaries who have always blamed a Jewish conspiracy for the crimes of Capitalism.
The antisemitic explanations for US foreign affairs clean the blood from the hands of the capitalist class; obfuscates the role of the capitalist class in government and society, to the extent that the capitalists seem to play no role in US affairs; and scapegoats the crimes of Capitalist-Imperialism onto the backs of a small ethnic minority, independent of their connection to Israel.
The US is motivated by its own interests. We should be able to identify the motivations behind US foreign policy while also understanding how the claim of, "Israeli control of the US," only serves to obfuscate the role of Capitalist-Imperialism in the exploitation and oppression of workers and the people of this world.
Not once, have I advocated for people to ignore the influence of Israel on US foreign affairs.