Memes of Production

You're proposing law being above any individual. How is that not rule over them even if you can't point out a specific person who implements or enforces it? That sounds more like direct democracy.

Yeah but like, what if some people want to punish more harshly than others? What if others don't want to punish an action at all?

Say someone from outside the community steals and eats a bull that was used for labor in the fields. The farmers want that person dead. An even amount of non farmers want that person simply jailed for awhile or have them do community service. A minority want no punishment because they believe stealing food shouldn't be a crime because the food is for everyone, and eating is a necessity.

Now how do you decide? What if the farmers just don't wanna follow the decision anyway? Then what do you do with the farmers since they went against the majority decision?

I can imagine organization, procedures, and community without hierarchy. I can also imagine that it can go wrong. If you think humans only work in Utopic ways, then that is a skill issue. Because when such events happen, not if, and there's no potential plan for it, guess what? That's when it falls apart.

Early humans by default operated on anarchism. There's a reason new methods of governing came to exist as societies grew much larger.