12

I just crossposted something using Thunder and another user let me know that my crosspost did not show that the other post was the original.

See here: https://lemmy.ca/comment/11901004

Not sure how that can happen but seems like a bug in Thunder then?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] darklightxi@lemmy.world 2 points 1 month ago

Just wanted to chime in here! I think the implementation of cross-posts is up for interpretation (and can definitely be changed if one is preferred over the other). Generally speaking, there are two types of implementations:

Cross-posts only copy over the title and link of the original post

  • This is what Thunder currently does, unless it's a text-only post (in which case, it copies over the text content of the original post since that's the only relevant part of the post)
  • The idea here is that we typically want to change the contents of the cross-post to be relevant to the community that we post to.

Cross-posts copy all content of the original post (title, link, body)

  • This is what Lemmy UI does, but it injects "crossposted from" into the body of the post
  • This can be useful if you want to post the same post across multiple-communities with the same body

From this discussion, I do think that it could be valuable to add an easier way to inject the original body of a post into a cross-post. If you would like this to be a feature, please create a new feature request on GitHub!


A side note on cross-posts:

I believe that Lemmy considers any posts with the same link as a cross-post. There's no distinction (from the API) on which post was the "original" post, or whether a post was crossposted "from a community" vs "to a community". This is also the reason why there is additional metadata for each "cross-post" in Thunder. The additional metadata allows you to figure out when a given post was created to find the "original" post.

If you're curious about specific implementation detail, @micahmo@programming.dev might be able to answer them!

this post was submitted on 28 Sep 2024
12 points (87.5% liked)

Thunder App

2806 readers
1 users here now

An open-source, cross-platform Lemmy client for iOS and Android.

This community is intended to discuss features and feature suggestions for Thunder; as well as friendly, respectful talks about Lemmy in general.

Please use the GitHub repository linked below to submit bug reports, so keeping track of them is easier, and make sure to search first if you already can find an issue for your report.

If there are any developers who would like to contribute, feel free to reach out on GitHub!

General Links
Website: Link
GitHub Repository: Link
Matrix Space: Link

Android Releases
IzzyOnDroid: Link
Google Play: Link

iOS Releases
Apple App Store: Link
TestFlight Beta: Link

Related Communities
Nightly Community: Link

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS