this post was submitted on 11 Mar 2026
38 points (95.2% liked)

science

25881 readers
439 users here now

A community to post scientific articles, news, and civil discussion.

dart board;; science bs

rule #1: be kind

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

"Stellar activity and plasma turbulence near a transmitting planet can broaden an otherwise ultra-narrow signal, spreading its power across more frequencies and making it more difficult to detect in traditional narrowband searches."

Science paper: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/ae3d33

Review article: https://www.theregister.com/2026/03/10/seti_admits_its_search_for/

Broadening of specral lines info: http://www.hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Atomic/broaden.html

top 10 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] Paragone@lemmy.world 4 points 2 days ago (4 children)

FFS..

SETI PRESUMES that the way we're going to detect extraterrestrial civilizations, is their beaming TONS of photons at us, in crisp signal.

WHY TF would they do that??

Why wouldn't they ditch the energy-wasteful TV-style broadcast, for energy-efficient fiber-optics?

There's, in my view, only a SINGLE century of civilization-evolution in-which tons of broadcast energy is poured helter-skelter all throughout the sky.

Before that it isn't done because the tech doesn't exist, & after that, it isn't done because it's idiotic to be doing it.

So, instead of presuming "all civilizations are broadcasting, why aren't we seeing them??", we OUGHT be presuming "we're trying to see a single-century of civilized-evolution, & maybe this is the wrong method for finding other-world's life".

_ /\ _

[–] khannie@lemmy.world 8 points 2 days ago

They do factor all that in to their thinking and also look for things like pulsed lasers. They're not idiots like.

[–] andallthat@lemmy.world 3 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Maybe there's some alien civilization who's actively pointing a radio signal in our direction so they can communicate with us. I don't know.... maybe the aliens are observing how friendly we are to each other and really want to connect?

[–] RickyRigatoni@piefed.zip 2 points 2 days ago (1 children)

Like what we do with things like arecibo.

[–] kalkulat@lemmy.world 1 points 1 day ago

Yeah! Like, hmmmm... was it really a storm that brought Arecibo down? Or ... was the storm just used as a cover by ET hackers?

[–] jordanlund@lemmy.world 1 points 2 days ago (1 children)

^ This!

We're already on the edge of point to point communication without radio waves so within another 50-100 years nobody will detect us either.

https://www.aliroquantum.com/blog/quantum-entanglement-communication

We're simply asking the wrong questions. Years ago I remember someone postulating the idea that if another civilization wanted to be found by another civilization, what they would do is find some interesting stellar object, and embed a signal in whatever radiation it was emitting.

So, another civilization would have to be a) capable of recognizing that object as interesting, b) have the capability and will to study it, and c) detect and separate a signal from the background.

The "You must be this tall to ride this ride" theory of interstellar communication.

[–] bunchberry@lemmy.world 2 points 2 days ago* (last edited 2 days ago)

Communication through entanglement still requires transmitting all the information you are trying to communicate through a physical communication channel like radio or some other channel like lasers or whathaveyou. The only supposed "benefit" of the communication is that it prevents undetected eavesdropping. Although, that's hardly even a great benefit, because you want to prevent eavesdropping, not just detect it, because that means the presence of an eavesdropper would kill all communication. There is thus not even a practical security benefit for communication through entanglement. It's largely overhyped. May have some niche use cases but not anything revolutionary.

[–] victorz@lemmy.world 0 points 2 days ago

Very good point. Having advanced life so close to us to clearly detect is wild enough, but to also snipe the direction and time window is absolutely crazy.

[–] Quilotoa@lemmy.ca -1 points 2 days ago (1 children)
[–] kalkulat@lemmy.world 1 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

Well yeah. But that's to be expected in astronomy, they have to keep changing the model as they learn more and more. Who knew 40 years ago that stellar atmospheres could broaden radio-frequency lines?

Fair cop ... but society's to blame !