The best explanation I've heard so far is that they were brasscrafter's masterworks. Difficult to make, no useful purpose, created entirely to show the skill of the metalworker. Masterworks made to mark the of end apprenticeships were a Celtic practice but brass casting and shaping like this was from Rome so these areas were the two culture overlapped.
Art Shareπ¨
This is a friendly community for everyone who wants to share their art with the world! Everyone is welcomed π¨
Please visit https://lemmy.world/c/artmarket as well! This is a community for artists to post their portfolios and announce availability to take commissions, as well as get visibility for Ko-fi, Patreon, and other funding for art activities.
Rules
AI Art: While we appreciate AI generated art, there are more appropriate communities to post that type of art to. Please keep posts to non-AI generated art only. This rule includes AI art that was then manually manipulated (e.g. drawing on top of something generated by AI).
NSFW Policy: Nudity and suggestive content has always been a part of art, but it may be something that some users don't wish to see or cannot view in certain circumstances (e.g. at work). If your work contains nudity or suggestive content, please mark it as NSFW. Work that contains nudity or suggestive content that is not marked as NSFW will be taken down. As long as the NSFW tag is used, we welcome nude or suggestive subject matter. If you aren't sure if your work is NSFW or not, just ask yourself, "Could I look at this at a typical office job and not get into trouble?" If you're still not sure after that, you should probably mark it as NSFW just to be on the safe side.
Spam: Please do not spam this community. Self promotion is fine if you just want people to be aware of your work, but blatant attempts at spam will result in the past being removed and possibly a ban. If you aren't sure if what you are posting is spam, please contact the moderator first.
Conduct: Be nice, and don't be a jerk. Constructive criticism is OK, but don't be mean. Encouragement is always welcomed.
That's where my mind went too. Just imaging how they got the balls on there. Was it one piece? Many pieces? How did they keep it from warping? How many attempts would it take? Crazy to think it was made at all
Its likely that they were sheets of brass cut, folded and soldered / brazed together, then shaped and cleaned up afterwards with files. Clickspring has videos going over some of the techniques likely used for constructing the Antikythera mechanism. They could also be cast. Ive seen examples which indicate both techniques.
One theory on the dodecahedrons ( and occasional icosahedron) was that it is of Celtic origin rather than roman, as the finding distribution more closely matches their regions, and the dodecahedrkn and icosahedron were considered holy symbols, akin to the cross to christians. This may explain their presence in army camps, where knitting is unlikely. Also there is little to no standardization on sizing or markings to indicate hole size, which makes it less likely to be for knitting or glove making.
Bro they are quite literally a knitting accessory, used to make glove fingers.
I'm a knitter. I can knit higher quality fingered gloves with double pointed needles (pointy sticks) way faster than anyone can use this as a jig to knit fingered gloves. And this idea completely ignores the existence of the different sized holes with the ring outlines.
Gloves were needed throughout the whole empire. But these don't show up throughout it. Knitting was pretty much limited to Coptic stitching on sock toes at the end of the Roman period. These objects aren't found near any Coptic area. Weaving and leather were the default materials for gloves. Knitting didn't really start until 3rd century. These show up a century before that.
So we have to ignore a lot about their design, age, geographic distribution and the inferior quality of the knitted results to accept they were used for knitting. Knitting doesn't pass the sniff test as a use for these long before we even get into issues like why they are never found where textile work takes place, aka around women.
Honestly, that's one of the weather theories proposed.
Weather? Weaker?
Lol
No, of course I meant weather. I lie, though
I lie, though
No you donβt
Well, fuck - you got me...
Β―\_(γ)_/Β―
Nice work! It's cool how crisp the forms are with such a sketchy style
With total understanding that there are no actual solid explanations, which do you personally lean towards?
I had to fight to keep outlines to an absolute minimum.
I'd hate to find out it's a game piece you toss dice into. I kinda like it as a mystery object. A true cult object.
Historians: they were likely some sort of religious object or something for maths or something very specific.
Tons of animals (especially humans) throughout history: I just like having this stupid, useless doodad.
How funny would it be if this was just a Roman fidget spinner? Maybe the reason that you won't find them in Rome was because some emperor got sick of the entire Senate fiddling with a toy in their hand while he was talking to them.
Notably, they're primarily found in Gaul and Germania, suggesting that they're not Roman, strictly speaking.
The ones in Germania have almost all been found in the Roman bits of Germania (i.e. east of the Rhine), and Roman Britain is the other big area for them, so it does seem like they're at least partially Roman. They seem to be called Gallo-Roman dodecahedrons a lot of the time because of the areas they're found in, though
These don't start showing up until the 300s CE but those areas were occupied since 100 BCE. So that's a 400 year gap. And they are always found in the presence of Romans, not indigenous locals.