Bible stories are the same way, we've just heard them a million times so they don't seem weird
"Hey Jesus what toppings do you want for pizza?"
"Plain with cheese"
Later the disciples are eating pizza with Jesus
""Hey Jesus why did you say you like cheese pizza when you normally order pepperoni?"
"You dumb fucks how dare you not understand my hidden meaning, I am the true pizza and you are the pepperoni, the grease is my blood"
"Oh of course, sorry boss"