Ow wow he guardian using a real headline.
Edit: nevermind OP had to change the propaganda.
this post was submitted on 09 Jan 2025
163 points (93.1% liked)
United States | News & Politics
7378 readers
451 users here now
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
Yikes, seeing people come out of the woodworks to defend slavery...
Person from Star Trek instance defending slavery is epsecially baffling, could be Gul Dukat alt account.
… Founders enter the chat …
So I think enslaves is a bit much here.
This is a voluntary program, and I'm not getting the impression it's the do this or we punish you voluntary either.
Meanwhile there are actual prisons that will force labor or severely punish you for refusing. That's enslaved.
It's also possible that the fire fighting is voluntary, but if not this, it would have been other mandatory slave work.
Yes there are slaves in prison, I'm just not entirely sure this specific circumstance is it. They are getting slaves wages though.
America incarcerates people for a ridiculous time and then lets them 'voluntarily work to shorten their sentence'. It's slavery with a little semantics.
As long as it's not forced (truly voluntary with no punishment) it's still not enslaving them.
I'm not saying it's good, but the title has an agenda.
What do you think about indentured servitude being called slavery?
I agree that's slavery.
There is slavery in the US prison system as well.
These prisoners are supposedly doing this specific job voluntarily, with pay. That is not indentured servitude.
These prisoners are supposedly doing this specific job voluntarily, with pay.
-
Being voluntary doesn't contradict slavery. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_slavery
-
Being paid $0.50 an hour, as opposed to $0.00 an hour, is trivial. If the slave-owners of old societies gave their slaves a penny a day, they would still be slaves for all intents and purposes.
While I personally haven't looked into this specific case, there is a very consistent and ongoing history of forced prison labor in the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_the_21st_century#Prison_labor
Inmates who refuse to work may be indefinitely remanded into solitary confinement, or have family visitation revoked. From 2010 to 2015 and again in 2016 and in 2018, some prisoners in the US refused to work, protesting for better pay, better conditions, and for the end of forced labor. Strike leaders were punished with indefinite solitary confinement.
That is forced work on an imprisoned person upon threat of punishment, even if they can theoretically decline it. This is a form of slavery, even if they get paid a dollar an hour.
That is forced work on an imprisoned person upon threat of punishment, even if they can theoretically decline it.
There is a history of this yes, but there is no signs that this is happening with this specific situation. I even said, if this case had that, it would be slavery.
The website for the program, while can't be fully trusted, explicitly states that this is not the case
An incarcerated person must volunteer for the Conservation (Fire) Camp Program and meet all eligibility criteria meant to protect public safety. No one is involuntarily assigned to work in a fire camp. Thus, incarcerated people do not face disciplinary action if they choose not to serve their time in a fire camp.
Edit: And just to be clear - Yes, they might be forced to do something else if not this, but that's probably up to the prison specifically. That alternative would be slavery, but these people are freely volunteering. They were not enslaved into this as OPs editorialized title implies.
Thanks for bringing up that program site (link, for convenience)
Like you said, it's hard to know the internal situation in the prison, so it's reasonable to want to avoid labeling this specific case as slavery or not without further evidence. The title is ultimately subjective, rather than the objective titles a news community typically encourages (by 'subjective', I'm referring to the fact that different worldviews have different interpretations of slavery, even up to the point where many through history consider regular work to be wage slavery based on a holistic analysis of labor in society)
Voluntarily risking their life for 5 to 10 bucks a day. Suuure.
If you'd like to provide any proof that these fire fighters are not doing this voluntarily and are coerced into it with some sort of punishment if not, please go ahead and provide it. Specifically this job, not others.
Also, you do realize that many fire fighters across the world are voluntary, in some cases the entire fire department is voluntary. People do risk their lives for this job for free.
And slaves voluntarily worked on the cotton fields. Great trolling.
Slavery should be abolished.
This shouldn't be a controversial beleif in 2025.
There was a proposition to abolish it very recently in California that was rejected by the voters. Commiefornia my balls
Californians talking about gluten-free free-range gender neutral Yoga: 😚🕊️
Californians talking about homeless people and drug addiction:
Fuck I was so disappointed and ashamed reading that in the election results
It is for a lot of people below for some reason.
load more comments
(1 replies)
Lmfao at the absolutely classic .world responses in this thread. "Slavery is good actually". You guys play your role too a T.
The ones in California are probably so glad they just voted in November to keep these prisoners enslaved.
Everyone who voted for that in LA deserves their home to burn, but I feel for all the working class casualties and people who were already homeless.
view more: next ›