this post was submitted on 19 Oct 2023
15 points (89.5% liked)
College Football
966 readers
1 users here now
A community to discuss college football.
| /c/CFB Poll Top 25 |  |
|---|---|
| 1. Indiana |  |
| 2. Ohio State |  |
| 3. Texas A&M |  |
| 4. Alabama |  |
| ~~5. BYU~~ |  |
| 6. Ole Miss |  |
| 7. Georgia |  |
| 8. Texas Tech | |
| ~~9. Virginia~~ |  |
| T-10. Oregon |  |
| T-10. Texas |  |
| ~~T-12. Memphis~~ |  |
| T-12. Oklahoma |  |
| 14. Utah |  |
| T-15. Georgia Tech |  |
| T-15. Vanderbilt |  |
| T-15. North Texas |  |
| ~~T-18. Louisville~~ |  |
| T-18. South Florida |  |
| 20. Notre Dame |  |
| 21. USC |  |
| 22. Michigan |  |
| 23. Miami |  |
| T-24. Tennessee |  |
| ~~T-24. San Diego State~~ |  |
Check out our other sports communities!
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Your first two examples open up more opportunities for outplays. The opposing team can recognize that you have picked up on their patterns and then run fake-out plays to catch you off guard. Sign stealing just allows you to know exactly what the other team is about to do and there is no opportunity for them to fake you out. (Other than switching to a new set of signs, but learning signs is boring for the players and not entertaining for the audience).
To equate it to poker: Your first two examples are similar to learning one of your opponents tells. If you start to exploit their tell, they can start faking it to force you to fold or place a bad bet. Sign stealing is like taking a peak at their cards
Actually a fantastic analogy. And like I said, I don't much care for sign stealing, I think there are better ways to more reliably put yourself in a position to win. I just think it's funny that we expect and even encourage the runner on second to watch the signs but as soon as it's somebody with a camera it's against the rules.
I don't see any material difference, signs can be changed easier than formations.
Stealing signs themselves isn't against rules, and is overblown. There was a pre-covid pro game where Tony Romo called basically every play as an announcer.