this post was submitted on 19 Jun 2026
61 points (100.0% liked)
RetroGaming
29096 readers
67 users here now
Vintage gaming community.
Rules:
- Be kind.
- No spam, AI slop, or soliciting for money.
- No racism or other bigotry allowed.
- Obviously nothing illegal.
If you see these please report them.
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Edit: Complete overhaul of my reply.
In short, this is a Remake of the first Mother 1 game on the NES, but using the modern Earthbound (Mother 2) engine on SNES. So you want to play the original instead. However they provide a second Romhack titled Giygas Strikes Back. I am not sure, but if I understand correctly this is not a Remake, but its EarthBound (Mother 2) with only bug fixes and quality of life improvements applied. If so, maybe this is the ultimate version to play instead the original game. Below is a sum up to the best of my knowledge and understanding.
Original Releases
Mother 1 is the original first entry in the series on the Famicom. It is released only in Japan, 1989. Much later in 2015 game was first time officially released in English in the US as EarthBound Beginnings on the Wii U Virtual Console.
Mother 2 is the sequel on the SNES 1994. It was also released in the US in English. Because no other game in the series was released prior, they didn't want to name it "2" and changed the title to EarthBound in the US in 1995.
Romhacks
EarthBound Beginnings Remake is a Romhack / Mod of EarthBound on the Super Nintendo. This is a remake of the first game from the Famicom / NES, using the modern engine on the Super Nintendo.
And when I understand it correctly, the second Romhack that is included here named EarthBound Giygas Strikes Back just contains all the bug fixes and improvements, but is not a Remake. So this is basically EarthBound with bug fixes. But I'm not 100% sure.
The only changelog they provide is https://ebbr.neocities.org/EBGSB_changes and titled List of all changes in the quality-of-life patch, EarthBound: Giygas Strikes Back!. But I could not find changelog for the Remake. I'm as much confused as you guys.
So Beginnings Remake is a remake of the NES game in a new engine and Giygas Strikes Back! is Earthbound US version with bug fixes?
If the NES game came first I should probably play that
The Romhacks are NOT for Mother 1 (which is known as EarthBound Beginnings on NES). They are Romhacks of Mother 2, also known as EarthBound on the Super Nintendo.
The Romhack is an attempt of Remaking the original Mother 1 on the Mother 2 engine. That is known as EarthBound Beginnings Remake. Then they offer a second Romhack, just called Giygas Strikes Back. If I understand it correctly, this is "just" EarthBound on the SNES with bug fixes. So they offer two Romhacks: 1) Remake of NES game, but on the Super Nintendo engine, 2) Bug fix of the EarthBound on Super Nintendo
Well done, thanks I get it now