this post was submitted on 14 May 2022
0 points (NaN% liked)

Worldbuilding

1482 readers
27 users here now

A place to share your original creations or those found from around the world.

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
 

For me, it's hereditary magic. I can deal with random people not being able to use a setting's magic (though I'd prefer magic to be accessible to everyone), but I hate the weird vibes that scream eugenics to me.

Naruto

My Hero Academia

Harry Potter

Just to name a few, take something as cool as powers and magic and turn them into things where you end up with characters incentivized to breed the perfect people.

Like I get people like the idea of going all Gregor Mendel with fire dad and ice mom to make a cool fire and ice kid, but then it's just gross and I don't know. It makes me think back to when I was younger. How so much of your life could be decided before you were born. I don't know, it didn't make it fun playing pretend.

What about you? What magic system tropes did you hate?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] bigbologna@hexbear.net 1 points 3 years ago

I don't know how to articulate this properly but I don't like when magic feels too much like its own thing separate from everything else or when it feels too much like a fully itemized system. It makes it feel like it's this entirely self-contained model bolted onto an otherwise normal world. This is something that's really more in games than anywhere else for very obvious reasons, but when magic is fairly common and magic is in the form of discrete known spells that always work the exact same way every time no matter who's doing it makes it feel really artificial and gamey in the same way that character levels being known in-universe would be.

I really like when you have things like every fireball or magic missile or whatever being slightly different the way that every handicraft is slightly different, even if it's the same "spell". I really like when there are outside forces that influence magic, like the planets are aligned correctly so everyone's magic is supercharged but unstable, or you're in a sacred grove so your spells do xyz things different, stuff like like that. Things that make magic feel like it's some supernatural force that you're tapping into instead of pressing a button .