DOJ Citizenship Revocation Plans Raise Constitutional Concerns
The Justice Department issued a June 11, 2025 memo directing attorneys to "maximally pursue denaturalization proceedings," sparking concerns about potential political targeting of naturalized citizens[^1]. While the memo lists priorities like national security threats and criminal conduct, it includes broad language allowing cases deemed "sufficiently important to pursue"[^1].
Legal experts warn this discretion could enable politically motivated denaturalization. "The politicization of citizenship rights is something that really worries me, I think it's just flatly inconsistent with our democratic system," said Cassandra Burke Robertson, a law professor at Case Western Reserve University[^7].
Recent events highlight these concerns:
- The White House press secretary indicated support for investigating NYC mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani's citizenship based on rap lyrics[^6]
- Trump suggested examining Elon Musk's citizenship status after Musk criticized his spending bill[^14]
- Trump threatened to revoke Rosie O'Donnell's citizenship, though this is legally impossible as she was born in the U.S.[^14]
Constitutional scholars emphasize that denaturalization through civil proceedings "lacks many constitutional protections," with no right to court-appointed lawyers or jury trials[^14]. The Supreme Court previously restricted denaturalization in 1967, ruling it "inconsistent with the American form of democracy, because it creates two levels of citizenship"[^1].
"Denaturalization is exceedingly rare and has occurred for people who concealed information of war crimes, Nazi membership, criminal histories, or immigration fraud such as using a stolen identity," said Michelle Mittelstadt of the Migration Policy Institute[^14].
[^1]: NPR - DOJ announces plans to prioritize cases to revoke citizenship
[^6]: MSNBC - Trump's DOJ issues memo on plan to strip citizenship
[^7]: CNN - Law used to kick out Nazis could be used to strip citizenship from many more Americans
[^14]: PolitiFact - Can Donald Trump revoke Rosie O'Donnell's U.S. citizenship?
this post was submitted on 03 Aug 2025
92 points (97.9% liked)
United States | News & Politics
3187 readers
1049 users here now
Welcome to !usa@midwest.social, where you can share and converse about the different things happening all over/about the United States.
If you’re interested in participating, please subscribe.
Rules
Be respectful and civil. No racism/bigotry/hateful speech.
Post anything related to the United States.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
LOL @america.
I’d say you’d all do something about this and overthrow the government, but you’re probably too busy watching Americas Got Talent tonight and eating tariffed chips.
Hey! How about you get your country to formally condemn our behavior.
Those of us protesting feel pretty alone when the rest of the world keeps bending the knee to our mad king.
Nah, clearly the person your responding to lives in a perfect utopia where their government and all citizens are flawless. There's a bunch of them on here.
I'm not very educated in global economics, but my best guess is that they need to move away from US trade first to minimize the backlash. I don't think the Trump administration will find much support after fucking around with tariffs, so maybe it's just a matter of time.