this post was submitted on 29 Jun 2025
-50 points (13.2% liked)
Linux
8169 readers
431 users here now
A community for everything relating to the GNU/Linux operating system
Also check out:
Original icon base courtesy of lewing@isc.tamu.edu and The GIMP
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
No. You can edit the Kernel command line directly from GRUB before booting into anything else. That is the default behavior (with Debian).
Yes, it is more aimed towards "casual" users that want something that just works. But auto-updating policy is not really the point of the blog. Every distro is deciding that by themselves and will always be able to.
Why would I care about someone having physical access and able to modify grub even? Full disk encryption blocks any actual access to the data on the machine and if they already have physical access they can put a nail in the HDD. Point being they aren't accessing the data. Not sure what more you'd want.
The attack is known as the evil maid attack. It requires repeated access to the device. Basically if you can compromise the bootloader you can inject a keylogger to sniff out the encryption key the next time someone unlocks the device. This is what secure boot is meant to help protect against (though I believe that has also been compromised as well).
But realistically very few people need to worry about that type of attack. Encryption is good enough for most people. And if you don't have your system encrypted then it does not matter what bootloader you use as anyone can boot any live usb to read your data.
Full disk encryption is non standard and a PITA without a secure boot chain where the disk can be unlocked by the OS itself. If you have fun tinkering with your OS go nuts, but I want something that works every time even if install it for my mom. The current distro offerings aren't that.
Could be an idea to make it easier to set a grub password during distro installation, that I can agree on.
Luks, libreboot and your grub concern is addressed