This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.
The original was posted on /r/homeassistant by /u/aevans0001 on 2026-07-12 20:28:50+00:00.
I’m looking for an Alexa-type device that is not Alexa, and I’m curious what hardware people are actually using successfully right now.
My needs are fairly simple:
-
Reliable wake-word detection and good microphones
-
Home Assistant voice control
-
Ability to play my own music library
-
Compact enough to place near our pool
-
It will be under cover and kept dry, so it does not necessarily need to be waterproof
-
Decent music quality, or the ability to connect it to a better external speaker
My music library is stored on an Unraid server and available through Plex. I’m open to setting up Music Assistant if that is the best route.
My biggest frustration with Alexa is that it misses or misunderstands commands far too often. I do not want to replace Alexa with something that requires me to stand two feet away, yell slowly, or repeat every command three times.
I found this older discussion about the Home Assistant Voice Preview Edition:
https://www.reddit.com/r/homeassistant/comments/1jku1fe/alright_guys_be_honest_is_the_voice_preview/
A lot of the complaints were about poor microphone pickup, low speaker volume, slow responses, and difficulty hearing commands while music or a TV was playing.
For people currently using the Voice Preview Edition:
- Have the microphone and wake-word issues improved through software or firmware updates?
- How far away can it reliably hear you at normal speaking volume?
- Can it hear commands while music is playing?
- Is it reliable enough for family members who do not want to troubleshoot it?
- How well does it work with Music Assistant and a personal Plex music library?
- Are you using its built-in speaker, an external powered speaker, or a separate media player?
I’m also interested in what people are using instead of Voice PE. Satellite1, ReSpeaker, ESPHome devices, Raspberry Pi setups, or anything else that is reliable and does not look like a science project sitting on the counter.
What hardware are you using, how reliable is it, and would you buy the same setup again?