rogermccoy

joined 2 years ago
[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 2 points 8 hours ago (1 children)

Did they just re-release the 50th Anniversary issue and change the cover? That would track content-wise.

Entertainment Weekly's "The Ultimate Guide to Star Trek" 60th anniversary issue is largely a reprint of their 50th and 55th anniversary issues if the copyright dates in the indicia are any indication, though they definitely made some updates to keep it current by including more recent shows.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 2 points 5 days ago

Basically. I have a spreadsheet with 1,300 watch items. Here are the first 10:

All Our Yesterdays The Inner Light Time's Arrow Time's Arrow, Part II The City on the Edge of Forever Storm Front Storm Front, Part II Little Green Men Far Beyond the Stars Carbon Creek

It's been a lot of research and adjusting as I go along. Plus a lot of semi-arbitrary choices between Memory Alpha order, Star Trek Chronology order, etc.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 5 points 5 days ago (4 children)

If there's no new Trek, that means watching old Trek, right?

Trying to finish my full in-universe chronological franchise re-watch for the 60th anniversary, which means an average of maybe 75 minutes of watching Trek per day through September 8 if I want to get it to line up. I started back in April 2024, but there's a lot of Trek out there, and I'm already falling behind. (Ideally it would've been 58 minutes per day. This includes watching some episodes multiple times if they take place in multiple time periods.)

For what it's worth, we'll arguably get some new Trek soon whenever the "season finale" of Scouts comes out. 😂 Only one episode left if they don't get renewed.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 3 points 5 days ago (1 children)

If memory serves it started great with season 1, got gradually worse through early season 4, made a shocking comeback in terms of quality for the rest of the season, and then took a nose-dive with season 5. I'm curious how that ends up matching up with your viewing.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 3 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago) (1 children)

"All this seems to say that Starfleet Academy is a global hit for Paramount, reaching new demographics and new markets, but not a fit for the Sheridanverse Pro sports streamer Paramount+ was narrowed towards."

If that's true, I guess it's UPN all over again. Starts with Star Trek as the lead only to have it slowly sidelined by a focus on a different audience, including a focus on professional fighting. The only way it could be more like UPN is if it was getting ready to merge with a similar-sized service owned by Warner Bros.

Oh dang.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 3 points 4 weeks ago (1 children)

Resurgence had voice acting for the whole game.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 1 points 1 month ago

I was mainly using season 3 as an example, but fair point that they were referencing other shows from episode 1.

Heck, one of the first characters to speak on the show was Gul Evek, who had appeared in several episodes of DS9 and TNG starting with "Playing God" when he refused to help O'Brien with the voles.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 2 points 1 month ago

Still watching, mainly out of curiosity.

It's become more fun and less repetitive with the new Holodeck Rescues. I don't know that it really does its job of teaching STEM or much of any lessons, but it's relatively harmless.

That said, if I had kids I have no idea if this would hold their attention, and I'd much rather the hypothetical kids just watch Bluey instead.

But I'll probably continue to at least check out the new episodes just out of curiosity based almost entirely on it having the name Star Trek.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 7 points 1 month ago (2 children)

Voyager referenced or included TOS and TNG characters in at least eight episodes of season 3.

  • "Flashback" was the big Sulu/Rand/Kang 30th anniversary tribute
  • "Death Wish" had Q and Riker
  • In "Alliances" Tuvok talks about Spock and recaps the events of Undiscovered Country
  • McCoy was mentioned in "Lifesigns"
  • Data was mentioned in "Prototype"
  • Sulu was mentioned in "Tattoo"
  • Picard and Moriarty were mentioned in "Alter Ego"
  • Picard was mentioned again in "Scorpion"

That's basically a third of the season, assuming I didn't forget any. And that's not even counting things like the mention of Wolf 359 in "Unity" or the koon-ut-kal-if-fee in "Blood Fever".

And that's from the show that went out of their way to make it hard to use existing concepts.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 7 points 1 month ago

I like to think that the pepperoni pizza was a tribute to the 30th anniversary of "Threshold" on the same day, but the true tribute to "Threshold" was depicting parents stranding their offspring on a planet and then justifying that it was fine.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 8 points 2 months ago (2 children)

I've been doing a rewatch and making notes of things that are referenced later. Considering most classic Trek has a reputation for being episodic, you'd be surprised just how much gets referenced later, whether in a passing comment or an in-joke or something. The only episodes of TNG season 1 where I didn't spot at least a passing reference later was "Too Short a Season", "Home Soil", and "When the Bough Breaks". (The references to a few of the others are vague and/or arguable though, and admittedly "Knowing where that clip in 'Shades of Gray' is from" qualifies a few of them.)

So it kind of depends on how strictly you define "important." Most people could probably skip almost the entirety of TNG season 1 and not be that confused, but for example:

  • "All Good Things..." loses a lot without "Encounter at Farpoint"
  • "The Naked Now" is important to "The Measure of a Man"
  • "Haven" introduces Lwaxana Troi, Mr. Homn, naked Betazoid weddings, and the running gag of data being too precise. "In the Cradle of Vexilon" loses something without it too.
  • "Where No One Has Gone Before" is crucial in introducing the Traveler, and that plot continues into "Remember Me" and "Journey's End" and beyond.
  • "The Last Outpost" has first contact with the Ferengi, though you could argue that future Ferengi episodes make more sense without it? Though it's important to the game Star Trek: Resurgence.
  • "Justice" doesn't seem important, but if you skip it you won't know what Remmick's talking about in "Conspiracy".
  • "The Battle" isn't referenced often, but "Bloodlines" depends on it. Remmick mentions this one too.
  • "Hide and Q" introduces concepts like the Q Continuum, and the events of it lead to Q's status in "Q Who", which introduces the Borg.
  • "The Big Goodbye" introduces Dixon Hill and explains holodeck matter. The Jarada are mentioned again later too.
  • "Datalore" introduces Lore and the Crystalline Entity and explains Data's past, somewhat.
  • "11001001" is important to understanding "Future Imperfect"... though that episode isn't really referenced again other than that it introduces a fictionalized version of Nurse Ogawa. So is it still important if you skip both of them?
  • "Coming of Age" introduces a lot of the characters and concepts that will be in "Conspiracy". Fun fact: This is the first episode to name Murf's species from Prodigy.
  • "Heart of Glory" introduces Khitomer and gives Worf's backstory and sort-of sets up "The Neutral Zone".
  • "The Arsenal of Freedom" is the first mention of Crusher's grandmother from "Sub Rosa", but arguably more important for relationship-building between Crusher and Picard.
  • "Symbiosis" becomes very relevant in Lower Decks in the episode "Trusted Sources".
  • "Skin of Evil" features the death of Tasha Yar. Armus also returns in Lower Decks.
  • Even though the cliffhanger isn't followed up on, "Conspiracy" becomes important again in "The Drumhead".
  • "The Neutral Zone" pays off the hints that the Romulans were gone, though if you skipped "Heart of Glory" you didn't catch this in the first place, and "Angel One" arguably contradicted it. But this is the first hint of the Borg, as confirmed in "Q Who" and "The Best of Both Worlds".

I could add other subtler things, but those are some of the bigger ones just from that highly-episodic season.

[–] rogermccoy@startrek.website 2 points 2 months ago

I'm probably stretching, but as soon as I realized Jay-Den was a birdwatcher I wondered if that was a subtle tribute to Chris Cooper, writer of the Marvel Starfleet Academy series and host of Extraordinary Birder. (Cooper became briefly very well-known in 2020 when a woman called the police on him while he was birdwatching.)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Cooper

I haven't spotted it myself, but multiple reviews have mentioned the wall includes a mention of Peter David, creator of the Brikar, who first appeared in Star Trek: The Next Generation—Starfleet Academy: Worf's First Adventure, the first licensed novel (or YA novella really) based around Starfleet Academy. That was probably visible in episode #2, but I'll note it here because

  1. It's a standing set.
  2. It pairs well with the possible Chris Cooper allusion.

David was mentioned as being on the wall at https://nerdist.com/article/starfleet-academy-wall-of-honor-star-trek-easter-eggs/ and https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/list/every-star-trek-easter-egg-reference-in-starfleet-academys-first-2-episodes/.

view more: next ›