this post was submitted on 18 Mar 2026
3 points (80.0% liked)

stupidpol

131 readers
191 users here now

Socialism for sane people

founded 2 months ago
MODERATORS
 

https://redlib.catsarch.com/r/stupidpol/comments/1rvq8b6/white_collaroffice_people_going_around_saying_how/

There's an insecure narrative going around from white-collar/office people on Reddit where they claim that they could turn on a dime and easily thrive in the trades if AI wiped out their industry. These people literally believe that their superior intellect alone would allow them to dominate, and they also think you're crazy for believing that the physical aspect of the trades would be difficult for them.

Their overall impression of what it takes to do a trade is probably a combination of watching DIY videos on Youtube that show you how to make easy home repairs under perfect circumstances and the observation that "guys are always just standing around" when they drive by a roadwork crew (and it's probably the foreman and supervisor).

In fairness, I think there are probably a lot of white-collar people who could survive in the trades, but very few would actually thrive. There’s a difference between being technically capable of doing a skilled trade, and actually having the determination required to push through 5+ years of being the low man, doing all the shitty work, fixing your own inexperienced fuck ups, and learning to deal with all the fucked up and occasionally dangerous people. All for lousy pay until you work your way up.

Another point- To whatever extent some people may think it's not that common, there's still a significant cohort of higher-IQ people who work in the trades. How many of them do you honestly expect to hear in year three talking about how easy it is, mentally and physically, and how they already have it mastered?

In conclusion, I think there are a lot of white-collar people who would simply not be up for the work, no matter what. Many others could survive if they had to, but would be absolutely miserable and wouldn't thrive at all. Maybe 15% of the ones that tried it would thrive, if that.

top 5 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] Aeri@lemmy.world 1 points 6 hours ago

I interned at a company doing tradie shit, I've done freelance work, and my current job is kind of sort of almost but not quite tradie shit.

I would fucking love to have an office job that made no physical demands of me to be perfectly honest. Grass is always greener I guess.

[–] BranBucket@lemmy.world 2 points 18 hours ago

I've got a foot in both worlds, I have an IT education but have worked in or around skilled labor most of my adult life. Part of my current job even deals with training and evaluating people doing skilled labor.

In my experience, two kinds of people tend to do well enough to be described as thriving. Those who've worked with their hands before, either professionally or as a hobby, and those who approach the job with some humility and a mindset of wanting to learn and perfect a craft, similar to many artists.

It doesn't matter what your background is, white collar, blue collar, no collar, if you're overconfident and think a trade is going to be easy because you don't respect the mental and the physical aspects of the job, you're going to have a bad time.

[–] Tar_alcaran@sh.itjust.works 3 points 22 hours ago

In fairness, I think there are probably a lot of white-collar people who could survive in the trades, but very few would actually thrive.

Most people currently in the trades aren't thriving either.

[–] teyrnon@sh.itjust.works 2 points 1 day ago

As a trade jacker, it's possible, but a lot of work learning how to do things on the fly. You also need the tools.

[–] toad@sh.itjust.works 2 points 1 day ago

Yea well my escape plan is a pot farm