I agree with that AI answer, though you are of course completely right to distrust AI.
this post was submitted on 30 Nov 2025
5 points (72.7% liked)
The German Language
452 readers
13 users here now
Welcome to the place to learn the German Language! Come here to discuss topics or quirks related to the German language, ask any questions about learning German, provide tips to current learners, and share your journey through the German-learning process!
RULES
-
Make sure anything you plan on asking has not already been answered.
-
No harassing someone over their level of the language of German. Everyone starts somewhere.
-
No harassing period actually. Obviously no bigotry falls under this category.
-
In general, no low effort posts or spam. If you ask a question and it didn't receive much engagement, don't go on to ask it again immediately, at the least remove the original copy.
-
No NSFW. This rule has its loose limits and some exceptions (i.e. commenting on German "dirty talk" and whatnot is alright).
-
Mods are the interpreters of these rules, and have jurisdiction over other cases where a rule isn't explicitly mentioned here, but it is a common sense rule.
-
This community is largely for English speakers learning/discussing German. Other languages aren't outright banned yet, but expect minimal support. If other communities arise for German help in other languages, then those languages will be barred from this community in favor of the new one.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
I agree that “Ist es heute sonnig?” is the most normal way to say it, but obviously the verb is not in the second position because yes/no questions do not use V2 order.
Both are correct. Never heard the latter variant in daily talk though, AI is quite right here - it would be emphasizing the "today" part in an unusual way.
Without context though the answer is "guck aus dem Fenster?" :)
huh, the second version sounds more „real” to me, arguably less correct but more colloquial.
Never heard a single person in Germany use it that was around :D
Curious! Perhaps it's either a regional thing or just a different context association? I only think of the predictive version, a variance on "wirds heute sonnig?"
But then again with the pretense case it's not something I'd use either way I think to be honest.
Ja, du kannst beides verwenden / Yes, you can use both