843
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 12 Apr 2024
843 points (95.7% liked)
People Twitter
5383 readers
815 users here now
People tweeting stuff. We allow tweets from anyone.
RULES:
- Mark NSFW content.
- No doxxing people.
- Must be a tweet or similar
- No bullying or international politcs
- Be excellent to each other.
- Provide an archived link to the tweet (or similar) being shown if it's a major figure or a politician.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Yeah. I really don't like the mindset that Trump voters are evil or racist, they fully understand what he's about and they want it. A tiny percentage of them are that way; most are not. In my experience, Trump supporters I've talked to have been victimized by extremely powerful extremely expensive / well produced propaganda that's created this whole alternate reality in their minds that's extremely convincing, and they're just trying to do the right thing within that reality.
I don't know what the solution to that is, but treating them as bad people (and particularly, ignoring or downplaying the economic / societal abandonment of them that created legitimate anger and resentment which the propaganda can play into) is definitely not the answer.
I'm sorry, but those people have access to the exact same information I do. Maybe at first it was understandable that some people got taken in by it, but at this point there is no mistaking what Trump stands for, and anyone who continues supporting him is outright malicious or so ego driven they can't possibly admit a mistake and will definitely follow him to untold atrocities.
I hate the terms "both sides" and "America is divided" because it implies that there is some form of symmetry to this madness. This is not the case. Trump supporters can come back to earth any time they want, but I am absolutely not going to meet them halfway to their shitty fascist endgame, even if that means we get another decade of milquetoast liberal democrats.
No they don't. Or rather, the ones I've talked with extensively had no idea what was going on; media they genuinely trusted had given them this very incomplete, bizarre, and specifically constructed view of the world that was perfectly believable to them, but which bore absolutely no resemblance to reality. In particular it even has specific features to make it harder to be able to break yourself out of, make you resist learning new information that might challenge it. If you haven't had your brain inside that type of box or talked extensively with people who did it's sometimes hard to appreciate how pervasive and reality-defining it can be.
So like think of all those guys who went down to the border expecting there to be this army of Mexicans coming over and terrorizing the whole town, and they were ready to go down and help sign up for their patriotic duty to help, and they were surprised and confused when they got there and it was just a normal town. It's not like they were like "oh okay let me start shooting any Mexicans I see on the street because that's my main goal" -- they had a perfectly humane reason for being there, in their minds. They had a perfectly humane response (like "wtf these guys lied to me, what even is going on here"). It's easy to laugh at them because they were so wrong, but they really believed it. Because all the news they watch and all their friends they talk to and all the internet they observe told them that's what's going on.
I definitely will agree that there's a way-too-large minority that's like "hey I always wanted to shoot Mexicans / shoot up the Ramadan celebration / kill my family member who I suspect of being a Democrat." I'm not trying to give everyone a free pass. I'm saying that the root of it for a lot of the rank and file is being duped, not being evil.
(Not that that makes them any less dangerous of course)
Fully agree on this part. The movement as a whole and its leaders are extremely dangerous and evil, and the media for the most part is looking for any excuse to avoid saying "these guys are Nazis WTF how do we stop them," and "both sides" is one convenient excuse.
Well, but they can't. Not on their own. They're either going to realize the reality through some outside force helping them see the truth, or they're going to keep growing in numbers and fervor until their leaders can use them to enact a for-real fascist takeover.
So these guys who went to the border... Once they realized it was all fake, they swore off this media and stopped voting Republican?
I like the cut of your jib! It's too often I see blanket statements about all Republicans are Nazis, racist, etc. You can't understand your opposition or why they might believe what they believe if you just see everyone as cartoon evil.
I like the idea that "no person is the villain of their own story." As you say, they for the most part believe they are doing the right thing according to the information they've been subjected to. It's an incredibly difficult problem especially as we understand the importance of a free press.
No person is the villain in their own story, yet I see people blatantly run red lights nearly every day. Most people know perfectly well the shit they do is atrocious.
In my experience, it's mostly been the "You're one of the good ones!" type of racist that gets sucked in and consider it reasonable.
As in, without some seed of racism/misogyny/etc that propaganda fertilizer would mean nothing.
But that's my experience with magats I know.