308

I could not recommend AnySoftKeyboard to my mum. I could recommend Florisboard, tho.

Openboard is virtually dead from what I can see. So that leaves Florisboard as the only open source alternative (that I know of) that could really be used by the masses. And the world would actually be a way better place if we all opensource freaks could install Florisboard on our family/friends phones and them barely noticing anything weird.

The problem is... no word suggestions yet. It's been years and we are still lacking what is almost an essential feature of a phone's keyboard.

I wish I could really work on it, but I lack the knowledge to do so; so I hope I am bringing some attention to the project.

Is there any other alternative I am unaware of?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] JustEnoughDucks@feddit.nl 6 points 1 year ago

Why wouldn't you recommend AnySoftKeyboard?

I have used it for a few years. You have a ton of good setups, good language support with decent autocorrect. The only thing that is less intuitive is swiping to change keyboards and the emoji selection menu.

I guess the lack of a clipboard has burned me recently too (locked out of bitwarden because 2FA password was stored in bitwarden and the fingerprint scanner didn't work because I added a fingerprint)

[-] InstallGentoo@lemmy.zip 2 points 1 year ago

Florisboard has many good features and is insanely customizable which are not present in AnySoftKeyboard. The only thing lacking as of now is the inferior swipe typing and word suggestions.

[-] marty_relaxes@discuss.tchncs.de 3 points 1 year ago

Not asking to start an argument but do you know what those features and customizability optons are?

Because I am currently running a German/English/Terminal-mode multi setup with everything set up right around how I need and the customization in AnySoft keyboard was quite honestly astounding to me (if very cumbersome to discover everything).

So if Floris offers even more possibilities I am wondering what they could even be?

[-] InstallGentoo@lemmy.zip 1 points 1 year ago

I tried AnySoftKeyboard again as it's been a while since I used it and here are my thoughts.

  • FlorisBoard has a lot of small things that can make interacting with text easier. You can have a toolbar in addition to the number row which has buttons for copy, paste, select all, cut and paste. This eliminates the need for long pressing text to invoke these actions. There's a layout called "Quick Text Editing" in ASK but that disables the number row. This is quite a deal breaker.

  • It also has a clipboard manager which was missing in ASK.

  • You can add a secondary toolbar which has buttons for undo and redo. This is one of the most useful feature for me. It allows you to, well, undo and redo text basically everywhere. This is helpful since text input fields don't have a way to undo and redo text. It can be a lifesaver in many occasions.

  • Swiping left/right on the spacebar is faster and feels natural compared to ASK's one character movement per swipe. Swiping from one end of the spacebar to the other end moves the cursor by many number of letters depending on speed. On ASK swiping from one end to other moves the cursor by only one letter.

  • You can create custom themes on FlorisBoard locally by editing a few variables. This is not a huge thing but it might be useful.

  • In FlorisBoard long pressing letters inserts symbols instead of variations of the letter.

Of course most of these are small and won't concern most people, but these are good quality of life additions for me.

[-] marty_relaxes@discuss.tchncs.de 1 points 1 year ago

I see, that makes sense and is very interesting. I will remember this for some inevitable phase of going from never touch running system to ohh shiny down the road. While I suppose some of these are just things working differently on the two boards, I see your points.

Although I did learn in this thread that ASK also has a clipboard history and undo! Though - to be frank it is hidden under an up-swipe of the spacebar.

[-] JustEnoughDucks@feddit.nl 1 points 1 year ago

What features does it have that aren't present in AnySoftKeyboard?

By word suggestions do you mean autocorrect? That is really a dealbreaker for me with touchscreen keyboards and switching languages ๐Ÿ˜…

Trying it out now though.

Is there some way to get rid of the massive utility row? Or customize long press length? Or have only punctuatiom symbols on the period and numbers in the qwerty row? Doesn't work for the dutch keyboard for some reason.

[-] InstallGentoo@lemmy.zip 1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

What features does it have that aren't present in AnySoftKeyboard?

I wrote a long reply to another comment in this thread. You can check it.

By word suggestions do you mean autocorrect?

Word suggestions when you type a few letters. But yes it's autocorrect is severely lacking.

Is there some way to get rid of the massive utility row?

I believe it's called "smart bar". It can be disabled.

Or customize long press length?

Yes

Or have only punctuatiom symbols on the period and numbers in the qwerty row?

I don't know about this.

[-] noodlejetski@lemm.ee 2 points 1 year ago

wait, how does a supposed lack of clipboard (which ASK does support) cause you to lock you out of a password manager?

[-] JustEnoughDucks@feddit.nl 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

No I do not store critical passwords in my clipboard like the other poster suggested.

It was bad timing and stupidity on my part. A bit complicated. Story here:

I updated my Bitwarden encryption settings, so it kicked me out of every instance I had, which stored my password for my 2FA. Normally this is no problem because aegis has biometrics. I had added a fingerprint earlier in the day because mine wasn't working well, and didn't realize that it would shutdown fingerprint access to the app (and it sent no notification). I made a backup of the bitwarden database, but I chose account-locked encrypted because it was the suggestion.

I hadn't made a 2FA backup code for bitwarden yet because it doesn't prompt you to when setting up 2FA (at that point in time) like all other apps and I just completely forgot. Definitely fixed that now.

I had just used the password for Aegis earlier in the day because my fingerprint was being very unreliable (hence changing it later)

My server had a password backup, but I had moved a few months before and hadn't had time to set it all back up, and my harddrive encryption passwords were stored on bitwarden (backups on a paper I couldn't find)

Ergo, my clipboard would have saved me because I used my password like 5 copy actions earlier. I ended up getting access through a local app instance of bitwarden that hadn't received the encryption update while my computer was disconnected from the internet.

Stupid, but a clipboard would have saved me time and stress in that case. All od the stupid mistakes that culminated have been fixed now. Important lesson.

[-] noodlejetski@lemm.ee 5 points 1 year ago

so you mean clipboard history. ASK has got that too, just hidden a little bit, you need to swipe up on the space bar and long press the paste button on the menu that pops up.

[-] marty_relaxes@discuss.tchncs.de 2 points 1 year ago

Learn something new everyday.. Thanks! This is sure to come in handy at some point.

[-] JustEnoughDucks@feddit.nl 1 points 1 year ago

Huh, had no idea, damn i will have to find that! Thanks!

[-] Pantherina@feddit.de -1 points 1 year ago

They permanently store critical PWs in the clipboard? Hell no. Not even Florisboards internal one I would trust, even though assuring that is secure would be great

[-] noodlejetski@lemm.ee 1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

They permanently store critical PWs in the clipboard?

well, that sure would be an idiotic way of managing one's credentials.

[-] Pantherina@feddit.de 1 points 1 year ago

Even on latest Android, every foreground app can read "your clipboard". That is the (like everything in Android) very basic 1-entry one. Florisboard is great if you preset the right stuff, as the internal clipboard can replace it (sync from system) but you can disable "sync to system"

Just make sure to always copy with the Keyboars and not the system popup, which UX-wise is absurd

[-] unknowing8343@discuss.tchncs.de 2 points 1 year ago

Once you use Florisboard you realise that even with all those options in AnySoftKeyboard, you cannot fully setup something as modern, well-functioning and organized as Florisboard.

There is one thing that makes me shut AnySoftKeyboard down everytime I come back and try it, which is that, when you hold down a key to show the alternative options... you have to really put your finger up over the options to select them... but only from the second row up. Makes no sense and no one seems to realise how wrong that is.

[-] JustEnoughDucks@feddit.nl 1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

I just tried it for a few days. Using it right now. I think in 2-3 years it sill be a pretty functional keyboard for more than monolingual people.

It's super uncustomizable now and not very functional (for me) right now.

  • There are open bugs because there literally no autocorrect (well one bug was closed but people aho use the beta release say that it still doesn't work. This makes it take 2-3 fimes longer to type anything without tons of mistakes.

  • Haptic feedback only works if you force ignore system settings even when system vibration is on

  • no option to split up punctuation between comma and period so you have to search throufh a giant menu much more slowly

  • no keyboard layout options

  • "smartbar" auto hide (when enabled) simply never ever hides

  • spacebar swiping quickly doesn't act reasonably. It pushes you 6-7 characters into the new paragraph

Your critique about AnySoftKeyboard is weird because people don't realize how wrong it is because it doesn't happen to them. You just have to hold and release for the symbol. You can slide left or right and definitely do not have to have your finger on the symbol to select it. It is likely there is a bug on your system.

I'm interested in knowing what is "more modern, well functioning, and organized" about it if AnySoftKeyboard has more features, better language support, modern autocorrect and word fill, can have the exact same layout and 10 other layoits, and is more customizable.

Still haven't found a person who can list a feature that florisboadd has that AnySoftKeyboard doesn't, even thouvh multiple people have said "it has more features"

[-] unknowing8343@discuss.tchncs.de 1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

We all know Florisboard has no autocorrect or word suggestions yet. The whole post is about this exactly.

Why would I want to hide the smart bar if it's actually useful, quick and modern, unline AnySoftKeyboard... which you have a set of options that either bring too little or too much.

No keyboard layout options in Florisboard? In fact, I can do something in Florisboard that I cannot do in AnySoftKeyboard in terms of layouts: I can pick a "spanish layout" for English language. Which is perfect because I hate having to change layouts and relearn key positions, something that AnySoftKeyboard forces you to do.

In terms of features that Florisboard has that AnySoftKeyboard doesn't... how about a modern and useful top bar that does many more things than the static AnySoftKeyboard's? How about left-right movement with spacebar? How about swipe deletion? How about good-looking password manager integration (and not AnySoftKeyboard's aberration)? How about being able to separate layouts and languages? Clipboard support?

Many of the "cool" modular things that AnySoftKeyboard can do are:

  • for niche power users
  • things than can still be included eventually in Florisboard

The difference here is that for AnySoftKeyboard to include anything that Florisboard does right would require much more work, muuuch more work (basically a full rework of the app); whereas for Florisboard integrating a fancy layout would be... a simple, one file PR.

[-] JustEnoughDucks@feddit.nl 1 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

Why would I want to hide the smart bar if it's actually useful, quick and modern, unline AnySoftKeyboard...

Because it is literally not one of those things. It is almost a direct 1:1 copy of AnySoft's utility menu except takes up an entire new row constsntly without ever hiding and is missing a few things tbat Anysoft has like split keyboard. Literally the only difference between the two besides missing features is pop-up vs persistant taking up 1-2 extra rows.

how about a modern and useful top bar that does many more things than the static AnySoftKeyboard's?

Again, what feature that is more "modern and useful"? It is completely static except that it can be manually hidden until the next character is pressed. Why even have a hide button then?

How about good-looking password manager integration (and not AnySoftKeyboard's aberration)?

Have you ever actually used AnySoftKeyboard? They are literally the exact same down to the shapeHere is proof. The only difference is that AnySoftKeyboard respects light keyboard choice where Florisboard simply doesn't respect day/night switches for "follow theme" or "system time" and Florisboard does not work in Firefox where AnySoft does as we also see in my screenshots.

How about being able to separate layouts and languages?

That is pretty cool actually! It's really a shame that there is only one keyboard layout and it is per-language standard layout of what florisboard devs "think is right". Why can't i have a choice of better or worse bottom rows and only get to have the worst in florisboard? Also, Anysoft has different layouts per language, just not "mix and match"

Clipboard support?

Anysoftkeyboard has that. https://github.com/AnySoftKeyboard/AnySoftKeyboard/issues/3450

Again, very interesting board and in the future it can be great! Just not yet for me personally yet. I don't have a horse in the race, maybe the code is indeed much cleaner, better, and easier to maintain. Then it is definitely a much better future option!

It is just missing a bunch of features and advertising on a platform on the basis of "better, more modern and more features is disingenuous at best. I have a problem with people spreading disinformation and BS marketing buzzwords with no.justification as their advertisement. That's it.

[-] sxan@midwest.social 1 points 1 year ago

It crashes on me.

All. The. Time.

this post was submitted on 01 Dec 2023
308 points (98.4% liked)

Open Source

31718 readers
114 users here now

All about open source! Feel free to ask questions, and share news, and interesting stuff!

Useful Links

Rules

Related Communities

Community icon from opensource.org, but we are not affiliated with them.

founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS