Are you just looking for headphones, or do you need a mic on it, too? Because you get get away with a pair of sony mdr-7506's and a modmic for that. I generally think a boom arm and a real mic is better than 2-in-1 headsets in a lot of cases, but I also recognize the utility that committing to a microphone attached brings to the table. Those headphones are 80-90 bucks msrp, but everything's been going up in price so ymmv. And if you attach a modmic to them, your options, value, and repairability open way up. Those headphones are great all rounders and punch way above their weight, don't require an amp to get 90% of the oomph from them, but still have options later down the line if you so choose. And they're closed back.

IF you want open back, buy a pair of massdrop 6xx for 200$. Those have even higher value:price ratio. But those generally do require an amp to open up. Not a great amp, but an extra 200$ to step into a schiit stack would be minimum imo. I've bought too many little dac+amp combos and I just don't like them; the initial value is by far higher, but there's no upgrade path, they're usually shitty and don't have the wattage to drive authoritatively, and are aimed at basically kids and are questionably robust at best. Keep in mind, this option is both more expensive and doesn't net you a mic - but, it is a proper path if you want great quality stuff that you won't buy and soon after consider regretting. The sony mdr 7506 is great, but it is a cheap pair of headphones.

Friendly neighbor headphones that you might want to take a look at are the audio technica m40x. I don't like beyerdynamic because they have pretty high distortion. Counter strike players like them because they're bright as shit to hear footsteps, but I got that you like listening to music more and play rpgs; Deadlock is still too much of a wildcard at this point.

Also, Stray was really good but relatively short with basically no replayability.