this post was submitted on 08 Nov 2025
15 points (100.0% liked)
Starfleet Headquarters
117 readers
9 users here now
Starfleet HQ
The Federations source for all Star Trek news, updates, and discussion.
Rule 1 — Be Civil, Not Klingon
Engage respectfully with fellow crew members.
- No harassment, brigading, or trolling
- No bigotry (racism, sexism, transphobia, etc.)
- Disagreeing is fine, but personal attacks are not
Rule 2 — Stay On Topic
Posts should be related to Star Trek: news, updates, official announcements, or meaningful discussion.
- Off-topic content may be removed
- Memes should be quarantined under a level 5 containment field to !Risa@lemmy.dbzer0.com
Rule 3 — No Prohibited Content
Some things are not allowed aboard the ship.
- No spam or scams
- No illegal content
- No porn or sexually explicit material
- NSFW content must be properly tagged
Rule 4 — Gatekeeping Is Not Starfleet
You can have your opinions on what counts as “real” Star Trek, but forcing them on others is not allowed.
- Everyone’s perspective is valid, TOS purists and Lower Decks fans alike
- Keep debates about canon and quality friendly and inclusive
If you see a post breaking the rules, report it so the moderators can handle it. If you'd like to be a mod, shoot Stamets a message.
founded 4 weeks ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I think takes like this are funny because it's like you don't even realize that it will never happen, not even because of corporations trying to drain any property of every iota of value (which they definitely are), but because we as a species love retelling the same stories.
I guarantee you there is someone sitting at their keyboard right now remaking Gilgamesh.
So, I can almost guarantee the initial premise of 'futurama' was 'animated star trek, but incredibly low stakes and played for laughs'
Except they couldn't do it as star trek, so it had to be its own thing. Maybe it would always have been IRS own thing, and the writers knew this.
20 years later they actually did 'animated star trek, but low stakes, played for laughs'. And it was good! I enjoyed it!
But even with the benefit of a more permissive format and two decades comedic distance, 'the lower decks' only holds a candle to 'futurama'. 'The lower decks' was shackled to existing versions of the story, their storytelling conventions, and their setting lore. 'Star trek' has to be post scarcity, has to be at least broadly Utopian, and centers around the fundamentally well intentioned usually competent always hierarchally organized 'big good' organization of the setting.
'Futurama' can have a sewer mutant who thinks she's a mystery alien because her mom had a PhD in linguistics, a billionaire heiress who's slumming it, a completely inane bureaucrat, and a robot devil who lives in new jersey. They can layer in deeper meta-jokes, like bender subtly actually being the greatest bender unit ever made because they're doing the world building from scratch, and can generally be meaner to/about their characters than anyone tied to 'star trek' would ever be allowed.