this post was submitted on 18 Feb 2025
48 points (92.9% liked)
Privacy
894 readers
261 users here now
Protect your privacy in the digital world
Welcome! This is a community for all those who are interested in protecting their privacy.
Rules
PS: Don't be a smartass and try to game the system, we'll know if you're breaking the rules when we see it!
- Be nice, civil and no bigotry/prejudice.
- No tankies/alt-right fascists. The former can be tolerated but the latter are banned.
- Stay on topic.
- Don't promote proprietary software.
- No crypto, blockchain, etc.
- No Xitter links. (only allowed when can't fact check any other way, use xcancel)
- If in doubt, read rule 1
Related communities:
- !opensource@programming.dev
- !selfhosting@slrpnk.net / !selfhosted@lemmy.world
- !piracy@lemmy.dbzer0.com
founded 3 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
the need for a telefon number is still a deal breaker. And having to "relock" the phonenumber every week in the app if u used someone elses number (so they cant do account takeover) sound just like a trap
I agree needing a phone number is a dealbreaker, the reasoning I've seen is:
My opinion?
In general, signal has proved they store no data besides the phone number itself, and in court they have only been able to give phone numbers.
Now it's up to privacy oriented users like many here to think about ways of getting a burner phone number for his without their name on it.
But I still agree with your point, they could work on better or more private ways of using Signal.
My problem with signal is actually this, because it's only part of the story.
Let's say the FBI suspects you of doing something horrible, like say you played baby shark in public. They have good cause to believe you're a Signal user, so they get a judge to authorize a subpoena based on your phone number, and Signal complies - and, yes, all they're doing is confirming to the FBI that you have an account with them.
Now they're going to go after you with 'We know you have a secret messaging app you use, Signal, and we know you used it to plan playing baby shark at the mall last Tuesday.'
And so, if you're not really clear on how all of this works, it's a fantastic wedge to try to pry actual incriminating information from you. Or, hell, you let them look at the app on your phone negating the whole damn encrypted part in the first place, because you're sure they already know.
Properly secure messengers shouldn't be tied to that level of PII, because, well, cops can still try to use it to bludgeon you.
Maybe a little paranoid, but I've decided to embrace some of the paranoia since not doing so means you have to trust in the rules and policies that the law puts in place and well, uh.....
They have no data of you to share with the FBI. No list of your contacts, no list of your groups, no data of stickers you use, basically nothing. That's what's great about Signal.
I suggest that you read their transparency reports to see what I mean. They share redacted version of their communications with the govts: https://signal.org/bigbrother/santa-clara-county/