interestingasfuck

And all of Polynesia, it’s just really hard to see a bunch of islands.

Bonkers that people managed to navigate to those islands without GPS.

that's why they get excluded from all the others

Somebody just doxed the whole of New Zealand

I don't see it. I know Australia is just around the corner to the left, and Chile to the right, but based on all of my other maps, that's just empty ocean! Anything else is woke.

Adding /s because someone will take me seriously...

https://nordpil.com/static/images/ocean_productivity_full.png

A picture's worth a thousand words. By far the most productive regions of the ocean are the shallow waters of the continental shelves. Maybe you could have an ocean world that was entirely shallow seas. But when I imagine an ocean world, I imagine abyssal depths spanning an entire planetary surface. Such a world would have far less ocean abundance than our own.

It wouldn't be a complete desert. Plenty of life does exist far from the continental shelves. It's just that these are the most productive regions of the ocean.

The problem with life is you need more than just water. Living things are mostly water, but the water is the boring part. And a lot of the essential building blocks of life tend to fall out of the water column as marine snow.

In shallow water, the depths that light can penetrate can also interact with the ocean floor. This allows more churning of vital materials. Plus there is a constant flow of new minerals and nutrients flowing in from the land.

In a deep ocean world? There would be very few minerals and nutrients available at any depth light could reach. Some would still work its way up through the action of currents, but nothing like the shallow waters.

And then you have to consider the nightmares Nature spawns, with terrors beyond any found in our oceans. A neat thing happens with oceans if you make them too deep. Pile enough water on top of water, and exotic high-temperature ices form under all that pressure. Some Super-Earths host oceans of scales beyond comprehension, but they are vast deserts made of water. If you kept piling water on Earth's surface, once the water got about 600 miles deep the exotic ices would start to form. This depth will vary based on the size of the planet, but for any given size, passed a certain point, the ocean has ice at the bottom.

And that is a problem for life. The water column is now cut off from the planet's crust. Volcanoes might periodically spew out some material through the ice shell, but we're already talking low-productivity worlds to begin with.

Now a shallow ocean world, a planetary continental shelf? THAT would be something to behold. But such worlds should be rare. Your ocean depth has to be tuned just right. On the scale from "mile's deep ocean" to "planetary desert," a planetary 100-foot deep ocean is just to the left of being a planetary desert.

Yeah, most likely.

But I had already typed the comment before realizing that and the sweet sweet internet validation from upvotes doesn't make itself

Ocean worlds would be less likely to be able to make and control fire, which is likely one of the main reasons we have any technology at all.

It's reasonable to assume that a world that is completely covered by ocean has no technology or sapient life.