wanted to check back in to say that the progess has been staggering, and I'm glad you've stuck with it. Eagerly awaiting the flatpak release
Linux
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Linux is a family of open source Unix-like operating systems based on the Linux kernel, an operating system kernel first released on September 17, 1991 by Linus Torvalds. Linux is typically packaged in a Linux distribution (or distro for short).
Distributions include the Linux kernel and supporting system software and libraries, many of which are provided by the GNU Project. Many Linux distributions use the word "Linux" in their name, but the Free Software Foundation uses the name GNU/Linux to emphasize the importance of GNU software, causing some controversy.
Rules
- Posts must be relevant to operating systems running the Linux kernel. GNU/Linux or otherwise.
- No misinformation
- No NSFW content
- No hate speech, bigotry, etc
Related Communities
Community icon by Alpár-Etele Méder, licensed under CC BY 3.0
Given the first few commits referring to scaffolding phases and the frequent use of em dashes, I’m suspicious this was built with AI assistance. Nothing wrong with that, but a disclaimer of some sort somewhere would go a long way.
What part, if any, does "AI" have in the development or use of this?
from the gitignore:
/.agents/
/.claude/
/CLAUDE.md
/PHASE1-PROMPT.md
/RELEASING.md
/skills-lock.json
/plans
so probably quite a bit lmao
and from a brand-new account too. this is slop, people
Does this "dev" even know vibe coded slop can't be licensed?
According to who? Was there a legislation or legal case? In which country?
The US copyright office for one
https://www.skadden.com/insights/publications/2025/02/copyright-office-publishes-report
Human authorship is a bedrock of copyrightability, and thus works entirely generated by AI are not copyrightable. (...) Where a work includes both human and AI-generated content, only the human contributions are potentially copyrightable.
That article ~~completely~~ practically skips over the section in the report that says that copyright can be applied by compilation to an overall work. See section II - F: "Modifying or Arranging AI-Generated Content"
Or you can also just skip to the conclusion of the actual report itself:
As described above, in many circumstances these outputs will be copyrightable in whole or in part—where AI is used as a tool, and where a human has been able to determine the expressive elements they contain. Prompts alone, however, at this stage are unlikely to satisfy those requirements.
https://www.copyright.gov/ai/Copyright-and-Artificial-Intelligence-Part-2-Copyrightability-Report.pdf
Edit: The article you linked does mention that the works can be copyrighted as a whole, but it does not mention this in the conclusion.
According to the U.S. Copyright Office, it absolutely can, but it depends on how much control the user exerts on the final product.
If a single prompt was used and they copy pasted the entire thing, then yes, as you have said, it is not copyrightable.
However, if multiple prompts were used and the end result is compiled/arranged with enough direction by the end user, then it can be copyrighted by compilation.
Generating content with AI is often an initial or intermediate step, and human authorship may be added in the final product. As explained in the AI Registration Guidance, “a human may select or arrange AI-generated material in a sufficiently creative way that ‘the resulting work as a whole constitutes an original work of authorship.’”¹²⁶ A human may also “modify material originally generated by AI technology to such a degree that the modifications meet the standard for copyright protection.”¹²⁷
As several commenters noted, human authors should be able to claim copyright if they select, coordinate, and arrange AI-generated material in a creative way.¹²⁸ This would provide protection for the output as a whole (although not the AI-generated material alone).¹²⁹ A relatively common scenario in registration applications is the combination of human-authored text with AI-generated images. In one early case, for instance, the Office found that the selection and arrangement of AI-generated images with human-authored text in a comic book were protectable as a compilation.
I would say a great part of this code was at least "AI touched". There are em dashes in the rust scripts, in the markdowns, in the commit messeges. @Simohypers@lemmy.world - disclose your stuff man! people should know what they are putting on their computers
If you view the first commit, you can see the CLAUDE.md, so at least in part vibe-coded.
Tbh all the vibe-coded apps look the same, and the UI has that vibe-coded style, so I'm not surprised.
Pretty tired of people posting slop they don't understand.
This is going to break in a few weeks when YouTube changes again. This is such a waste everyone's of time. Just noise distracting from people who actually understand the things they build.
Wow. I’m not a YT music person and MacOS is my daily drive, but this looks incredible. Well done and a very nice contribution to the community.
Go ahead and sign in with your YouTube Gmail credentials, he or she won't automatically store them for future use.
The source code is open and on Github, and there is also a guide to compiling and running the code locally, if not trusted. I can see that being a paint point though.
But the option of listening to music without signing-in is available. 👍
Ah that's good. I never sign up to the radio. So basically I don't wish to login to listen to music.
Best of luck with the YouTube interfaces - anything I have coded to them dies within a year or less due to them changing the rules.
On the flipside: awesome app, probably worth the effort to keep whacking the moles as they come up. Good job so far.
First of all, I like rust+tui stack and thanks to sharing to community,but I hate to see open source dev wasting valuable time on reinventing wheel on something constantly change. YouTube's api, webpage constantly change to prevent third party sw. While we have invidious which can be use as backend, why ppl want to waste their time and abandon project quick? Freetube can use invidious api as source for example. What we need make invidious more backend friendly (i always confused why invidious dev not focus on their api only) and able to have single source of truth on subscription, history across mobile, desktop frontend app
Linux folks be like: I don't have a good enough tool for this niche thing. Guess how my next 1000 hours will be spent? 😄
Seriously though, nice work!
Certainly looks interesting, but I have to mention that I'm not a fan of the Discord Rich Presence feature. The directory access that this typically requires immediately bumps up any flatpak to a medium risk category.
Granted I'm definitely one of those users that does not care to share my current status to all other users as to what I'm watching/listening to at every moment.
This looks great and I'll give it a go.. but have you heard of grayjay?
Holy shit I'm bookmarking this for when I get a moment to test !!
Thank you so much for this, been looking for a Metrolist-equivalent desktop app and this is just lovely <3
One thing I noticed, when using the appimage playback fails continuously with
app_lib: track failed error=Couldn't load this track — YouTube rejected the stream link
and even thumbnails can't be downloaded. But building from source and using the limusic-app binary directly works perfectly.
Thought not being signed in was the issue, but the build from source works just fine, so maybe an appimage issue?
thank you for sharing. love metrolist and the idea of having a desktop equivalent.
There's also pear desktop but it's sort of a web wrapper for the stock yt music experience, and likely has a comparable memory footprint to your situation having it as a pinned browser tab.
I'm always curious about youtube music apps, it seems like there are so many of them everywhere, even f-droid has like 20+ clients listed that all look very similar.
Maybe just a fun app to try making so a lot of people do it?
If you add support for archive tune's remote play you could be a great companion app and make my need for spotifies remote play gone!